Crappie

[Deadeye]

Def Pygmy sunfish but I would think you would want something bigger.

 

[Deadeye]

Bluegill is a dream sunfish of mine, but probably maxes out too big.

 

[Bradyfam]

I know a bluegill is two big for that tank so I was thinking a redbreast, warmouth, or pumpkinseed

 

[The Masked Shadow]

Redbreasted and Pumpkinseed would be fine. Add dithers like Mosquitofish and/or Shiners.

 

[KATALEKEEPER]

lets use the process of elimination!

what fish in the leopomis complex get to big for a 40 gallon?

• green sunfish
• bluegill
• redears

what does that leave?

• ellasoma
• longears
• pumpkinseeds
• dollar sunfish
• banded sunfish

I hope that clears it up

 

[Bradyfam]

Thanks so much for the help