custom made vs buying

  • We are currently upgrading MFK. thanks! -neo

ITHURTZ

Piranha
MFK Member
Apr 11, 2007
1,846
38
81
Antioch IL
I am just thinking of ideas. I could build a 180gal tank with stand, acrylic hinged top and a 48x24" viewing window for $600

A all glass 180gallon with stand and top is around $1000

Would there be a profit in making tanks this size or bigger/smaller or are the deals on craigslist/ebay to much for this to be a reality?
 
i'd rather pay $1000 for a full glass tank/tops with stand over $600 for a tank with a small viewing window and an acrylic top that will sag,stand or not.
 
think about how long the tank will last, cost of repairs and most importantly resale value.

maybe I'm way off but this is what turns me away from DIY tanks.
 
for the 400 bucks diff i would go store made

unless i wanted to have something to say look what i made though diy almost always has issues

look at what happened to the monster fish rescue 800g
 
i would think that 600 is alittle high for home built,
on ebay you can get a 1/2" 48x24 sheet for around 50-100 dollars shipped. price of lumber is way down.
Not sure what your measurements are but i wouldnt think youd need more
than 1 sheet of 3/4" plywood, a few 2x4 s for the framing, bracing. Then your sealant, and paint id think more around 400..
sheet 48"x24"x1/2" $50-$100
Marine Ply $50
2"x4"x12' @ Ace $2.50ea
Fish safe paint ? $50.. ?
fiberglassing or other sealant $100 maybe $150
Oak or other Trim Wood $50

Your looking at around $400


Its when you go over 48x24 that ebay dont really have anything. and you have to go to a dealer.

Just my 2 cents
 
6x2x2, 2 sheets of ply

On ebay I have never seen 24x48, let alone at half inch that cheap. I just bought a 39x8 acrylic window on there (1/4) and that cost me $20 shipped.
 
I give people quotes on custom tanks all the time, only had one taker so far. Unless it's a build in place monster (real monster - 500+) it's really tough to compete with manufactured tanks for the quality, price, warranty, and so on. If you did manage to build a 180gal tank for $600 and sell it for $1000 you're looking at probably 100 hours to do it **right**, maybe you could get that down a very long way by repeating the process, having jigs built ahead of time, etc, etc, etc. But with an average joe shop, even 40 hours is pretty optimistic (again, to do it to the level that you're comfortable selling it to someone else to put in their house), and then you're working for around $10 per hour.

I know someone will chime in and say they can do it in a weekend, and I'm sure you could, if you did it a few times before, or had a full scale professional workshop, or else did it super crappy, but factoring in design time, trips to the store for stuff, applying sealant in several coats, glueing and screwing every joint, bondo, finishing the outside, getting it to the customer's house, blah, blah, blah, 40 hours goes by FAST.
 
MonsterFishKeepers.com