Cycling a 720 Gallon System, Couple questions...

  • We are currently upgrading MFK. thanks! -neo

davenmandy

Peacock Bass
MFK Member
Feb 1, 2012
1,781
459
122
So my plywood 8x4x3 has been filled and running for 3 weeks now. So I poured 3/4 of this stuff in day 1 and then the rest 2 days later.:

http://www.bigalspets.ca/multi-purpose-bio-support-16-fl-oz.html

I also had about 7 rotting smelt in the tank for about a week and a half.

For reasons that would take a bit long to get into here I also started running a drip a week after, I realize this probably prolonged everything, but it was something that needed doing given the circumstances as it would have made life a lot more difficult in the future if I didn't, long story short it would have hurt another tank that I run my drip system through if I didn't since my system is unbelievably finicky and we are talking about tanks on different levels of the house, etc.. Started dripping roughly 150 GPD, moved it up to 200 this weekend with a bit of hot water because my tank temp in the basement was sitting a bit low. I got a large, close to 2 foot arowana last week from a friend as this fish has been proven to be extremely hardy (was 3/4 dried on the floor one day, thrown back in, perfectly fine, third suicide attempt) and the thought was that it would help the tank cycle.

For filters I am running 1.75 cuft of k1, does not appear to be seeded yet. I also have about 1/4 of a 55g barrel filled with bio balls and pot scrubbies. I placed 3 large (7" diameter or so if it were a perfect circle) bags full of ceramic rings in my overflow box as well, these were nice and seeded. There is no substrate in the tank currently, I am unsure if I will get some or not, I would like to get another 1.25-1.5 cuft of k1 but don't know when I will be able to grab that for cost reasons. Tank is roughly at 6x turnover, maybe 7.

I tested the water yesterday: 0 ammonia, 0 nitrite, 10-20 nitrate. Arowana still hasn't eaten in his new home, but I am not so concerned because it was a big change in environment for him, and he shows interest in the food just doesn't pull the trigger.

I would like to put at least 2 large stingrays in the tank, 18-24". These things have obviously huge bioloads, and I am unsure when would be safe to introduce them. My understanding is there is only enough bio bacteria that is required for the bioload, so once I toss one of the stringrays in there I imagine there will not be enough BB in there as right now it only is supporting a silver aro that doesn't eat (therefore doesn't produce waste). I imagine there would be a spike or crash of some sort, how big I have no idea, nor do I know if my big rays would be able to handle it.

On to the questions:

First off, do I have enough bio media to even support these fully cycled? I think I do, though not sure about k1 not being seeded yet.

How much longer should I wait before adding the rays?

Should I be adding one at a time or is both in 1 go the better option?

Is there anything further I can do to prepare or is it a question of putting them in and hoping the bacteria grows and seeds quick enough? I am thinking maybe see if I can get another large hearty fish, or maybe letting some more stuff rot, or adding more of the bottled bacteria, or taking substrate from my established tank and putting it in the plywood. Unfortunately stopping the drip would be a large set back, if it is determined I absolutely need to do this I am open, otherwise it stays as is.

Any other thoughts? I only ever worked off previously established filters and media and substrate and simply transferred tanks, of course I have cycled smaller tanks but never anything this large. I would like to get these rays moved relatively soon as I would like to find another male breeder and offer some more space, however I know rays are REALLY sensitive to this sort of stuff, so I want to make sure I am doing this right.

Thanks in advance, I am sure I will have more questions.

millerkid519 millerkid519
CANAMONSTER CANAMONSTER
Lepisosteus Lepisosteus
Dieselhybrid Dieselhybrid
wednesday13 wednesday13
duanes duanes
 
You will definitely get a spike when you add two huge rays. If you have an other sump or something to help seed your system that is ideal. Or go buy a bunch of big cheap fish and through them in lol. The rotting fish I don't like as it can introduce fungus and bad bacteria.
 
  • Like
Reactions: davenmandy
Just the gravel in my 400. I already took the ceramic rings from the sump. I could take half of that and move it over if needed, don't want to as then both tanks will only have a thin layer not enough for the rays to really dig and sift through, but I'd that's the difference I will.
 
What you do is put the new bio in the old tank system for a week and then put in new and repeat. Not quick but only thing I can think of. Or go buy like a **** load of cheap fish to help up your bacteria.
 
  • Like
Reactions: davenmandy
Hmm ya I can probably pack up a good amount of those bio balls and stick em in my 400 gal's sump. Or just swap them with the bio balls in the 400 a bit at a time. Thanks Mike.

Any other thoughts?
 
  • Like
Reactions: Dieselhybrid
just letting you know from what I have heard from a few people is k1 takes a long time to cycle. I would wait longer before adding the rays, then when you do decide to add them add one at a time. The buy cheap fish route is always an option, with this warm weather you could buy a few $10 koi and have little to no problem moving them on to someone this time of year. They will produce a hefty bio load with all their waste. And always check the local listings, im sure someone us looking to rehome some bigger fish, the only problem with that is rehoming them after you get them. Adding a bit of the gravel from your old tank will help as well
 
  • Like
Reactions: davenmandy
IME time and patience are the best for cycling new big tanks on an autodrip... Sounds like u covered all the bases using some old gravel/media and a hardy fish to start out.. Not much else u can do now to speed up the process.. Over the years i become almost overly patient when it comes to moving fish...but whats the rush? Anymore i wait a good month or longer before adding anything i truely value to a new system. I start with some cheap dithers after 2-3 weeks... wait it out a couple more weeks and start adding my nice fish/rays one at a time, every week or 2 weeks once i feel confident all is well. Take ur time and ride out the urge to drop em all in lol... itell pay off in the end... last 2 tanks i set up fresh for rays 450 and 500 gal i waited almost 3 months to drop em in lol... overly cautious probably, but all went well and better safe than sorry. As for ur bio load supporting ur fish load, sounds like u have more than enough. I think 2cu ft of k1 can support 30lbs of fish and u have an additional media barrel on top of that.
 
Thank you for confirming my suspicions. Absolutely patience is a virtue, and I doubt I am going to find another male breeder soon anyway. But I am intrigued with maybe some temp monsters, maybe there is a big catfish on classifieds that I could keep for a few months, that actually sparked some good interest because I haven't kept anything other than rays in a while.

So I am able to wait, I have this technology (maybe someone has an app for that). I will look for some bigger fish cheap locally. Should I buy more of that cycle equivalent? Bacteria in a bottle? I say no because that doesn't address my bio load issue, so I feel it would be useless unless I have issues with subsequent fish.

This kinds of works nice cuz really I only have to move my male if I find a new one. Can't wait to get my 28" female in there though, top of her disk touches the euro brace while her feet are firmly on the ground :(

I'll take it week by week and keep an eye out for a male. Unless someone else had any suggestions to get it to seed quicker? I hate seeing rotting smelt on the bottom of the tank.

Arowana looks wonderful in there, healing nicely from a couple lost scales and ripped fins from thrashing around too much in transfer.
 
MonsterFishKeepers.com