Differing growth rates in the same tank

  • We are currently upgrading MFK. thanks! -neo

Throan

Feeder Fish
Jun 29, 2022
1
0
1
42
Hello everyone,

I'm keeping a tank full of Bichirs, 2 albino senegal, 2 delhezi, and 1 ornate. All were aproximately the same size when purchased. These fish have been kept together and all appear to be female. Their diet has consisted of the odd guppy, but mostly diced frozen shrimp, an assortment of sinking pellets, and bloodworms when they were smaller.

Now here is the rub.... 1 delhezi, and the ornate are turning into monsters with thick bodies, broad heads, and pushing 8" or so. One of the albinos is not to far behind at around 7", also looking full and powerful. the remaining delhezi is about 5.5" while the last albino is around 5" and they are both slender and delicate looking, not maintaining the thick bodies of the giants and i feel like they are growing much slower.

Is there a reason that this variation in growth rates may take place in fish that are all kept together and of similar ages? How can I address this, and for anyone that has raised Bichirs, should I be worried about the biggest killing or eating the smaller albino and delhezi?

They are currently in a 70G tank with sand bottom and a collection of nooks and crannies for them to hide and search in. Other tankmates are a school of 10 very large Tiger Barbs and a Hoplo around 6"
 
The bigger bichirs are likely the dominant ones, and are stealing food from the small guys.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Throan
In some species, the largest specimens will excrete growth inhibiting hormones so they can maintain dominance. Some folks use carbon or up their water changes. Not sure if bichirs do the same
Agree with this, and also that the larger "alpha" will obviously in combination with the hormones end up with more food.
Especially in small volume tanks, where growth inhibiting hormones quickly build up if a number of fish of the same ilk are housed together under a poor water change routine.
Ive seen this, and it can be very obvious where a group of similar aged cichlids are jammed together and 1 or 2 alphas appear to quickly grow, while others struggle to keep up, if not enough water changes are done and allow these hormones to build up into a stunting soup.
Many breeders holding grow outs in limited spaces change large amounts of water daily to allow more even and faster growth rates.
If your water change routine is 50% of the tanks water once per week, an easy and obvious experiment might be to double or triple the routine and volume for a couple months and see if that makes a difference.
 
MonsterFishKeepers.com