Diy radiant heat system for plywood tank

  • We are currently upgrading MFK. thanks! -neo

Mr.Gorby

Gambusia
MFK Member
Apr 16, 2018
8
3
18
29
I'm planning a plywood tank build that will be around 12-1400 gallons. As of now, the only concern I have is how I would heat the dang thing effeciently to keep electrical costs down. One bump in the road is that we built our house with a tankless hot water heater, so splitting off of a typical hot water tank isn't doable, and I really don't want to burn up our propane more, as our electric is cheap at $.05/kwh versus propane being like $2.50-$3.50 a gallon.
I've tried to check out some diy setups with a loop and either could not understand how it worked, or it used a hot water tank in one way or another.
I've contemplated maybe getting a small, dedicated HW tank to run? Or would I be better off to insulate the tar out of it with some R21 and foam, then just use a couple standard aquarium heaters? Trying not to overthink it but I sure can do that sometimes. :woot:

Appreciate anyone's $.02!
 
  • Like
Reactions: tlindsey
I'm planning a plywood tank build that will be around 12-1400 gallons. As of now, the only concern I have is how I would heat the dang thing effeciently to keep electrical costs down. One bump in the road is that we built our house with a tankless hot water heater, so splitting off of a typical hot water tank isn't doable, and I really don't want to burn up our propane more, as our electric is cheap at $.05/kwh versus propane being like $2.50-$3.50 a gallon.
I've tried to check out some diy setups with a loop and either could not understand how it worked, or it used a hot water tank in one way or another.
I've contemplated maybe getting a small, dedicated HW tank to run? Or would I be better off to insulate the tar out of it with some R21 and foam, then just use a couple standard aquarium heaters? Trying not to overthink it but I sure can do that sometimes. :woot:

Appreciate anyone's $.02!

I personally don't have any experience but hope this helps. https://www.monsterfishkeepers.com/forums/threads/radiant-floor-heating-for-plywood-tanks.594856/
 
If you're decided on using an electric heater you won't get any more efficiency out of any other heating method than a regular aquarium heater. If you insulate the tank and room well enough you can get away with using as little as 1 W/gal in my experience.
 
  • Like
Reactions: tlindsey
If you wish to use electricity, look at heat pumps for swim pools/spa's as they have 650 - 700 % energy efficiency. So using 1 kilowatt of electricity will produce 6.5 to 7 kilowatts of heat.

While insulation is definitely recommended, having a covered roof or lid is more important as 70% of heat loss is through the exposed water surface.
 
MonsterFishKeepers.com