DIY: XXL External Canister

  • We are currently upgrading MFK. thanks! -neo
Thats probably the cheapest option, though if you are looking to make something that would require a FX6 you should also look into a wet dry sump. if you look at more of Joeys videos he has a few which describe wet/drys or drip sumps. If you build one using one of those plastic organizers like he suggests you don't even have to stop water flow when you are cleaning.
 
Thats probably the cheapest option, though if you are looking to make something that would require a FX6 you should also look into a wet dry sump. if you look at more of Joeys videos he has a few which describe wet/drys or drip sumps. If you build one using one of those plastic organizers like he suggests you don't even have to stop water flow when you are cleaning.
I have seen most of them, theyre really useful.
I had thought about the sump, but because the tank will be in my bedroom, id prefer to be as quiet as possible.

I understand sumps can be quite loud? is that right?
 
well if you use the same pump as Joey suggests the DCT 6000 that shouldn't be any louder. and if your referring to the suction noise that a lot of overflows or bulkheads make you can fix that by extending the pipe above the water line to allow air, the gurgling noise is air trying to enter the pipe so if you go out of the bulkhead and use a T, then send one to your sump and the other above the water line you can allow air to enter and exit, which will stop the gurgling, there is a name for this pipe which i cant think of im sure someone will enter it below, if you want to find it now however you can look at Joeys explanation of the plywood aquariums filter he mentions it there. The drip tower shouldn't make more noise then an HOB and if you run into issues then just try to eliminate how far the water falls before hitting more water. My personal aquariums, up until this point, haven't been large enough to warrant anything other then cheap Chinese canisters.
 
I have seen most of them, theyre really useful.
I had thought about the sump, but because the tank will be in my bedroom, id prefer to be as quiet as possible.

I understand sumps can be quite loud? is that right?

I am running a 55 gallon sump under my 220 and it's completely silent with a herbie style overflow (mine is actually a dual herbie). The only thing I can hear is the hum of the RIO pump I that I'm going to replace with a DCP 8000 (I already have one of these DCP 8000's, as my setup is a dual pump setup, and it's also completely silent). Once the RIO pump is replaced I don't think I will hear anything unless I really try to. I am pushing about 1600gph through my tank.

Definitely look into the Jebao DCP pumps as they are extremely quiet (they are two generations newer than the DCT pumps) and are very adjustable. I can use the settings on my DCP pump (can be adjusted between 30 and 100% by single increments) to tune my herbie overflow.

How big is the tank?
 
I am running a 55 gallon sump under my 220 and it's completely silent with a herbie style overflow (mine is actually a dual herbie). The only thing I can hear is the hum of the RIO pump I that I'm going to replace with a DCP 8000 (I already have one of these DCP 8000's, as my setup is a dual pump setup, and it's also completely silent). Once the RIO pump is replaced I don't think I will hear anything unless I really try to. I am pushing about 1600gph through my tank.

Definitely look into the Jebao DCP pumps as they are extremely quiet (they are two generations newer than the DCT pumps) and are very adjustable. I can use the settings on my DCP pump (can be adjusted between 30 and 100% by single increments) to tune my herbie overflow.

How big is the tank?
Oh okay, will keep all that in mind. Didnt realise it could be so quiet :)

At the moment its a 4x18x18. But im building a 6x2x2 next week, so its for that one.

If im being honest, I'm a little scared of sumps, given I dont feel confident in setting one up, even though Ive watched dozens of videos on them
 
https://www.monsterfishkeepers.com/...ome-help-with-noise-reduction-options.680720/

Here is a thread I made about noise reduction, but it also has a ton of pictures of my setup. My tank is a 6x2x2.5, so similar to yours.

Honestly, I felt the same way about the sumps as you do. I wanted one but I was just not that comfortable with them, especially because I tried a small ten gallon sump on my 29 with a diy pvc overflow and it overflowed within the first two weeks. I still decided that I wanted to drill my 220 and set it up with a sump so I cam up with the setup that is in the thread I linked. If you take your time and set it up correctly, and make sure you have redundancies, it is a very reliable system, and is super easy to maintain. Also, my entire sump build probably cost least than $200. Let me know if you have any questions about my build and, even though I don't have a ton of experience, I will do my best to help you out.

Another option if you don't want to go the sump route would be three or four of the SunSun 304B canisters. They are under $100 and my 303B is extremely quiet.
 
I am running a 55 gallon sump under my 220 and it's completely silent with a herbie style overflow (mine is actually a dual herbie). The only thing I can hear is the hum of the RIO pump I that I'm going to replace with a DCP 8000 (I already have one of these DCP 8000's, as my setup is a dual pump setup, and it's also completely silent). Once the RIO pump is replaced I don't think I will hear anything unless I really try to. I am pushing about 1600gph through my tank.

Definitely look into the Jebao DCP pumps as they are extremely quiet (they are two generations newer than the DCT pumps) and are very adjustable. I can use the settings on my DCP pump (can be adjusted between 30 and 100% by single increments) to tune my herbie overflow.

How big is the tank?
Or you could go with a 75 gallon sump. Bigger is always better.

I was able to set up a completely DIY sump for about $400-450, and it's the best filter I've ever owned. After a month of waiting for deals on Craigslist, I found a 75g sump that needed resealing for $25. After adjusting the baffles to my need, and creating a drip plate, with $100 worth of acrylic, I was able to put it media, which set me back another $50. Plumbing was about $100, and I picked up the pump from Lowes for around $125.

Sumps are easy to set up, even if you start with a bare tank. The baffles aren't very complicated, just make sure the water flows in the opposite direction of the previous baffle (over, under). Plumbing also isn't that bad. I have two 1" bulkheads on my 210, which is considered below average for a tank my size, although they keep up with my 1400gph pump fine. I'm no expert, but two 1-1.25" drains should work well with a tank that size, depending on the flow you want.

Maintenance is also quite simple. Replace the socks every couple to three weeks, and clean the bottom of the sump every few months.

If you don't want to go this route, a single eheim 2262 would cost less money (than two FX6s), and would filter the tank better than the FX6s.
 
MonsterFishKeepers.com