Do you have a hero notatus?

  • We are currently upgrading MFK. thanks! -neo

Snowflake311

Piranha
MFK Member
Jan 24, 2010
1,081
28
81
Lake Tahoe, ca
I just got a baby notatus and would love to see yours. So if you have some I would love to see them. If you have before and now shot even better.

Here is my little 1" baby
P2242682.jpg

P3012695.jpg
 
Here's a young wild-caught male.

ea341536.jpg


I have some of the F1 notatus from Jeff Rapps. I am still unsure if they're actually hybrids or if notatus fry were mixed with rotkeil fry. Sometimes groups of fry get mixed. Whatever the case, out of five fish, two are very distinctly rotkeil and the others are... not. They are much darker in color with black spots and they're developing a nice greenish yellow base color on the head and chest. I'll try for some updated pictures of them later.
 
I received an email from honda today. I will post my full reply below for anyone to whom this may apply.


Thank you for your email 'honda'.
I was made aware of this two weeks ago from both XX and XX (I did not think it's my perogative to list first and last names on public forum).
Both gentlemen are long term customers and I consider them to be both
knowledgeable and professional in their role as advanced aquarists.
After I received photos from each of them, I saw what they were referring to.

Here is a copied portion of email I sent to X:

"The only plausible explanation I can imagine to be the cause of two Heros spp present in the same tank occurred to me as I'm writing you. My sons and stepsons were all working out in the facility doing water changes over the spring and summer.
Maybe I did hatch some rotkeil eggs in another tank on same rack as notatus fry. It's the warmest rack in the building, so that's where I would place little Heros.
If one of them accidently sucked baby cichlids into the hose, they'd been instructed to place a net over the end of the hose that drains into the floor drain to catch the babies.
If they did this and put baby rotkeils back into a tank of baby notatus, that would explain the presence of both species in same tank.
Hopefully mystery solved.
Please let me know how many rotkeils you have and how many notatus you have."


I am sorry if this happened to the fish you received as well. Just as I gave each of them credit on orders I sent to them last week for any Heros that were misidentified, I am offering you the same credit on the one notatus you ordered as well.

The fry which I raised were bred here in my facility from a wild pair of adult notatus. I also had wild rotkeil adults at that time - in completely different tanks.
There are no hybrid Heros circulating, 'honda'. Each of the above gentleman received individuals of both rotkeil and notatus, as they concurred and showed to me in current photos.

I would ask that you please restrain from making heretic statements about this mix up as if it were a akin to a mass recall by Toyota.
It's the very first time such a mix up occured in over 15 years of business where tens of thousands of fish are bred and distributed world wide from my facility.
I've been doing this far too long, under the highest scrutiny of all - my own standards, to accept the following as general opinion:
"so what is it? You need to fix this because people are doubting your fish
now."

In other words 'honda, I wish you could have been a little more tactful or polite and less accusational in your initial email.
As I said, I am sorry for this mix up. I accept full responsibility for this situation and would communicate the same to anyone who may contact me regarding same subject.

Best regards, Jeff
 
I am sorry Jeff, I should have came to you before believing what I have heard, and given you a chance. Please forgive my rudeness, the email was sent through my phone so I can sound like a jerk when I am not trying to be. Thank you very much for clearing this up. I will still do business with you.
 
I'm X.

Received them 8 months ago when they were under 1". Took a while to realize some weren't notatus. Got frustrated, contacted Jeff, received credit, used it toward some beautiful new fish and all is good.

Happens to everybody (probably more often to people with hundreds of thousands of fish). Difference is how one handles it afterwards. Matter resolved...moving on to enjoy fish keeping....

Edit - sorry for the derail...here is a video to keep it on topic ;)
[YT]<object width="640" height="385"><param name="movie" value="http://www.youtube.com/v/UvoUV4ZRH0A&hl=en_US&fs=1&"></param><param name="allowFullScreen" value="true"></param><param name="allowscriptaccess" value="always"></param><embed src="http://www.youtube.com/v/UvoUV4ZRH0A&hl=en_US&fs=1&" type="application/x-shockwave-flash" allowscriptaccess="always" allowfullscreen="true" width="640" height="385"></embed></object>[/YT]
 
jgentry;3982112; said:
Peter should have lots of Notatus pics to display. He stole an excellent pair from me at the Atlanta auction:).

lol I offered to buy the pair from JD but he wouldn't sell them to me....had to steal them in the auction :nilly: I believe JD got them from John (snookin21)

Here is a poor picture of the male - day one in the tank. They are beating up on my rotkeil pair now :(
Heros_notatus_030810_01.jpg
 
Thanks guys. They look good. I can't wait to see if mine if male or female. I have a strong feeling it a girl but that should work out well with my stock. I just love how the males look.

Thanks for posting. If anyone has more show them off.
 
MonsterFishKeepers.com