Does anyone out there own a G6?

  • We are currently upgrading MFK. thanks! -neo
S

snow

Feeder Fish
MFK Member
Feb 19, 2009
1,498
2
0
B.C.,Canada
Not the plane, the filter.;)
How are these filters? Do they work well? I know it a lot of money for the filter since the flow rate is not the best but I want to hear some comments from the owners of these filters. I don't want to hear from people who don't have first hand experience with them.:nilly:
 
I saw one in person today at a LFS. It is TINY! Some of the features are interesting, but for the price I would much rather get a few FX5s.
 
Definitely just get a FX5.
 
got one to try out from a LFS owner here in socal. not worth the money, at all. i'll stick with my old eheims.
 
yeah ive seen em in person, read reviews. definately not worth the hype and the price.
 
i dont have one so i shouldnt chime in, but based on it's features, it's made for the guy that likes to show off how much money he has. kinda like those 'more-money-than-sense' folks :)

the cute little LCD screen displays dont give you any useful information. and dont get me started on the glossy black/chrome finish. pure marketing fluff.
 
I don't have one but I would rather buy a sump, the plumbing, an Fx5, take the wife out for a meal and still have change left over for fish food.

I like the idea of a quick clean cartridge but the only brand as far as I am aware is Hagen's own so they can charge what they like, £28.99 for the pre-filter cartridge and £18.99 for a nitrate/phosphate one at the moment.
I can imagine it being really good on a small tank but lots of fish keepers want good flow as well as good filtration, not for a filter to excel at one and be crap at the other. They dropped the ball with their research on both the G3 and G6, I for one do not believe they consulted potential customers as they claim.
 
cichlid2006;4491581; said:
I don't have one but I would rather buy a sump, the plumbing, an Fx5, take the wife out for a meal and still have change left over for fish food.

I like the idea of a quick clean cartridge but the only brand as far as I am aware is Hagen's own so they can charge what they like, £28.99 for the pre-filter cartridge and £18.99 for a nitrate/phosphate one at the moment.
I can imagine it being really good on a small tank but lots of fish keepers want good flow as well as good filtration, not for a filter to excel at one and be crap at the other. They dropped the ball with their research on both the G3 and G6, I for one do not believe they consulted potential customers as they claim.
Click to expand...

I agree... if they had we would have an updated FX5 with a couple better features. Not a small overpriced flashy canister with cartridges.
 
I don't think it's necessary to have "first hand experience" with them to make an educated guess. If you've been around the block more than once you should recognize all the warning signs of a hustle. Chromed-out shiny "cute" box for cleaning fish ****? The specs (flow rate, etc.), price, and that ridiculous LED screen speak for themselves. Not only would I get a FX5 instead, I would probably take a Fluval405 over the G6. It's like putting lipstick on a pig. Also, reminds me of the story ab out how the US spent millions designing a pen that would write in zero Gs while the Soviets just used a pencil- ie you can get the same job done without all the unnecessary gadgetry and expense.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
MonsterFishKeepers.com
Top Bottom