does this sound alright

[gcull6]

i want all these fish to go into 4ft tank.

2 silver dollars
2 archer fish (toxxtes jaculator)
2 fire mouths
2 bella sharks
4 clown loachs
3 kuhi loach
1 gold datnoid
2 spotted scats

this will be a fresh water tank, would this tank be over stocked

 

[spiff]

I think so.

 

[cassharper]

extremely. If it's 4 ft, then it's a 55g or a 75g. Either way, you don't have enough swimming room for those balas, enough room period for the clown loaches, the water is too not-brackish for the archers and scats, and that dat is gonna be hurting for space.

Please don't go with that stocking, pick something you like more about it and go that way. Themes are always helpful, and you can find many different kinds to fit in a 55.

the only think that would be monster in that tank would be the lack of space (sorry, had to hit up the pun)

 

[Bogwoodbruce]

Very overstocked, ditch the firemouths they will probably be too agressive, and ditch the koolie loaches they will become food.

 

[gcull6]

so if i got rid of the archers, scats, kuhli loach and fire mouths would that be alright

 

[haynchinook334]

whats the dimensions of the tank? you can have a 4'x4'x2' size tank...and that will work. but we need to know the size tank you have at hand to answer your question.

 

[uncwnells]

I agree with the people above, there are too many fish from random biotopes, which means each requires different parameters.

 

[gcull6]

the tank is 4 by 2 by 2
so if i had

2 silver dollars
2 bella sharks
2 clown loachs
1 gold datnoid

would that work

 

[kydsexy]

nope, clown loaches should be in groups of 5 or more
a dat will need a tank of 125 or better
do you mean bala sharks? they're a no also


but the silver dollars are all good

 

[Wolfsting]

Very overstocked, ditch the firemouths they will probably be too agressive, and ditch the koolie loaches they will become food.

lol? firemouths like the least agressive fish on the planet i think a seahorse is more aggresive