Eheim 2028 or DIY bucket sump??

  • We are currently upgrading MFK. thanks! -neo

malawi500

Candiru
MFK Member
Sep 29, 2011
319
12
48
UK
I have an 80 gallon tank and running one Eheim 2028 although I'm not too impressed with the water clarity.

I have caught the fish bug and been reading up about wet/dry sumps.

If I were to ditch the Eheim 2028 in favour of a DIY sump would I be mad to do so?

Having read up on DIY sumps I think it is something I could easily knock up using 1" pipework and a simple overflow system.

The Eheim is capable of 277gph so I would need something more powerful than that. I was thinking along the lines of 400gph ie. a turnover rate of 5x per hour.

According to this sticky here:
http://www.monsterfishkeepers.com/forums/showthread.php?205645-Pipe-Sizing-Charts-and-Flow-Rates

1" pipework would give me a flow of 600gph and I am confident I could knock something up.

The only space I have for a sump however would need to fit in 12" x 14" x 24" (high) cupboard underneath the tank.

If I were to use a bucket type sump as per this youtube vid:
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=FkT9EiY9v60

and fill the bucket with pot scrubbies and filter floss as the pre filter, would this offer better filtration over and above the Eheim?

I'm tempted 'just because I can' but wondering if the gain is worth the effort?

If I were to do this I'd sell the Eheim to fund the project.

Advice appreciated.
 
I run an fluval xp5 and a fluval 305 canister filters on my 220. My tank was never real clear. I built my 20L sump and overflow with pre filters in my drip tray and my tank is crystal clear now. I use all 3 filters on mine. In my canisters I don't use the polish filter material only medium in those.
 
MonsterFishKeepers.com