eheim 2028 vs 2250/2260

[pesky2118]

I have a 125g tank that I want to get a canister for. The tank is a in-wall design that seperates a living room from a dining room, therefore the canister filter will be the only source of filtration, no HOB's to accompany for aesthetic reasons. I had hoped to build a wet dry, but due to space issues underneath the cabinet, I don't think that is realistic, and I don't want an overflow box to hang off anyways.

I've found the 2250 for 199 online, vs the 249 for the 2028, and I am unsure why its cheaper, since it seems superior in gph and volume. I'm thinking the difference is due to the 2028's basket design which simplifies use. Which is a better choice? For those who think the 2028 is a better choice, what about compared to the 2260 which I can get for 249, which is the same price as the 2028? Simplicity is not an issue for me, I want the best filtration, not ease of use.

stock list:
12" oscar
8" female texas (fully grown)
8" tinfoil barb
5" oscar
4" firemouth (fully grown)
4" midas

 

[Princley]

i'll take 2250

 

[rumblesushi]

def. the 2250, eheim classics rock, they have the intake at the bottom so no bypassing of media

 

[HarleyK]

Howdy,

The 2260 is flat out too big if you plan anything but a creek set-up. The 2250 would be okay. Since (to my knowledge) the classics do not have a throttle, the high flow rate is the most important aspect to consider. After all, you do not only want the best filtration, I assume you also want your fish to be comfortable.

The xx28 is barely suitable for your tank. I had the 2228 on an 80 gal, and used the throttle. Your stock list shows high fish density, though. Have you considered the 2080? It has a high flow rate, but it is adjustable. It offers the same media volume as the 2250. Therefore, I would say they're both adequate. The 2080 has the advantage of flow rate adjustment, which I love.

HarleyK