Electric Blue Jack Dempsey Tips

  • We are currently upgrading MFK. thanks! -neo

BlueJacks

Plecostomus
MFK Member
Nov 26, 2010
72
38
51
40
Massachusetts
Looking to see if anyone has had any luck with pet store Blues. Everytime I get them from a LFS they just die after 3-4 inches. Like clock work literally. Only fish I’ve kept that just had the sudden death syndrome.

just bought one and he’s already ****ting white. API general cure in the mix.
Other than breeding the blue gene types with a regular I’ve never been able to raise a blue to adulthood from the LFS
 
  • Like
Reactions: tlindsey
had the same issue as my got to about 4 inches lasted 2 years came home one day from work found it dead maybe getting one with good genes
 
I tried the EBJD about 10 years ago same issue but i tried doing 30 WC every other day and that seemed to work i believe the EBJD need pristine water i treated them like Discus after losing 3 of them. had it for about 1.5 years even hit like 6in
 
The problem with "line-bred for color" cichlids, (doesn't matter if its EBJD, or pink oscars, or EB Rams), is that to acquire the heavy desired color "gene" often sacrifices a gene that promotes good health, such as enhancing the immune system, or adaptiveness to things in the environment.
And those weak genes are not easily observed
Especially when the profit motive requires as many individuals in a spawn to survive, and are to be sold as possible.
In nature, in natural color populations, the weak are culled by natural selection (the survival of the fittest) so those that get to breed, are the best of the best, and those have genes that have been harvested from the wild, and are passed along in normal color fish.
Aquarium strains are often not sufficiently culled, are sold before weakness is noticed, so some of those weak individuals that do persist, and because they can sometimes survive in the somewhat protected environment of an aquarium, perpetually breed, and pass on more substandard genes.
Unless the aquarist provides almost sterile, perfect water, its seems albino/pink oscars are more prone to HITH, Rams have shorter lives, and EBJDs have the rep they have.
This scrambling out of "good genes" often seems to occur in hybrids, hence the tendency for FHs to have little resistance to diseases like Columnaris.
 
Last edited:
I have two EBJD in two different tanks with similar sized normal Jacks, and they can not deal with the aggression. They both got torn up within days, and I had to put them in isolation tanks. They are beautiful, but fragile.
 
MonsterFishKeepers.com