try nature coast exotics for alligators...I;m impressed that this is legal-given that one hurricane and whoosh! nile crocodiles in florida (this is not an exaggeration-they have nile crocs!)
also, if you really are adventurous, try getting a self import permit. My family got some zebra plecos that way, and we know someone who brought back dendrobates pumilio (blue jeans poison dart frog)