Fish Growth

  • We are currently upgrading MFK. thanks! -neo

yonk420

Feeder Fish
MFK Member
Sep 3, 2005
64
0
0
43
Gonzales, La
I have been doing some research on my fish and have come upon a problem. I have been noticing that my fish have been grownig (not that this is the problem!!) but I never had the right ph, the right temp, nor have I ever checked to see what my amonia, nitrate, other levels were at. I do a 10% water change once a month and was wondering if maybe it was because i have been keeping them in water about 75 degrees (I have cichlids). Any info would be helpful. :headbang2
 
What exactly are you asking? Good fishkeeping habits (keeping clean, stable water) are condusive to fast growth. However, some fish are very adaptive and seem to grow in anything. A lot of SA cichlids are examples of this. I'm guessing these are the type of fish you keep, eh?
 
they've been doing fine and adapted well so if it ain't broke don't fix it
 
when i saw your avatar i thought you were rallysman for a while. :screwy:
 
NIce avatar yonk420! Where's the cowbell? Anyway, fish do adapt. It may be not the best of situations; it's your job to do the research and provide the best environment for fish. However, it often happens that no matter how well you screw it up some fish will thrive anyway. This is not an endorsment for negligence, just a reminder that you are God and your responsibilities won't go away.
 
10% once a month? did you just buy fish and shove them in a tank without any research? try doing 30% once a week for healthy fish that will thrive. growth isnt conducive to good water conditions.
 
A well set up and established tank,with light stocking levels, good filtration including UGF, and lots of plants, can go for a lot longer than a week without a water change and still keep zero levels on the ammonia and nitrite levels. That being said it is still best to do partial water changes every one or two weeks, if nothing else you can use the time to really inspect your fish and look for problems in the tank.
Yonk,
I think you should go ahead and check your water parameters, ammonia, nitrite, nitrate, and ph, and then compare them to your dechlorinated tap water readings. I am betting that at least your nitrate levels will be high. Elevated readings, even if not in the levels that cause immediate damage, will lower your fishes ability to fight off disease, prevent the survival of any spawn, and in the case of long term exposure to high nitrate levels, open the door to HITH infections (esp. in larger cichlids).
The kits are not expensive or hard to use and improving those parameters will result in healthier, more robust fish that will reach a larger adult size.
The ideal readings are ammonia 0.0, nitrite 0.0, nitrate 20.0 ppm or less, pH varies for the type of fish, what you are mainly checking for is any change between your tap water and your tank.
 
guppy said:
A well set up and established tank,with light stocking levels, good filtration including UGF, and lots of plants, can go for a lot longer than a week without a water change and still keep zero levels on the ammonia and nitrite levels. That being said it is still best to do partial water changes every one or two weeks, if nothing else you can use the time to really inspect your fish and look for problems in the tank.

very true guppy and most experienced fish keepers realise this. but in the WWW we in a way have a responsibility to with-hold some info from the public.. we have to try and remember that many newbie fish keepers are reading all that is written, they could be thinking 10% water change once a month is fine unless its mentioned.
i hope this comes across as a constructive point rather than anything else
 
Agreed :thumbsup:
 
MonsterFishKeepers.com