Geophagus group size

  • We are currently upgrading MFK. thanks! -neo

andy1985

Fire Eel
MFK Member
Aug 30, 2007
1,117
18
68
London
What is the best amount of Geophagus for a group? got a 6 x 3 x 2 tank which will end up housing an asian arrow, but want some Geo's in there as well.

Kind Regards Andrew
 
As juveniles, generally 5 or more for most true Geophagus species if you want to see their social group behavior. Similar with Satanoperca, 5 or more. As adults, pairs tend to be perfectly content to themselves in a community with other compatible fish and, depending on species and temperament of individual fish or pairs, may actually be calmer that way-- again, that depends on things like gender mix and temperament of a particular group or pair. It can go both ways ime.

I've had and seen some very nice tanks with 7, 8, or more in a group, such a shoal can make a nice display. Then again, adult pairs of a large, high bodied species like altifrons have plenty of presence on their own.

G. brasliensis and closely related species are a bit different, different fish, really, and generally more belligerent, not as social, except when small.
 
  • Like
Reactions: PhishMon84
I usually suggest "at least 6 Geos", but which Geo species preference might may depend on. flow rate....
Many rheophillc Geos prefer (and do best in) highly oxygenated water, with brisk flow rates
Arrows usually prefer slow to moderate flow rates.
IMG_5317.jpegIMG_6951.jpeg
 
A group of 6 Geo's may do okay if they stay grouped together, but alone will probably be killed by your Aro.

Honestly, it probably depends on the size of the Aro.
Depends on relative size. Large aro and small geos could be a problem, but I've seen plenty of tanks with arowana and geos. That said, for a 30" arowana, you'd probably want one of the larger growing geo species. :-)
 
  • Like
Reactions: Tristan's 6000 Fish
I usually suggest "at least 6 Geos", but which Geo species preference might may depend on. flow rate....
Many rheophillc Geos prefer (and do best in) highly oxygenated water, with brisk flow rates
Arrows usually prefer slow to moderate flow rates.
Agree, though the true rheophilic geo species (such as agyrostictus, taeniopareius, and harreri) are comparatively uncommon in the hobby compared to the better known high-bodied geos which, while they do need good oxygenation, aren't fussy about current, many of them spending time in calmer water.

 
Yes, I have seen Aros and Geos together, but the Geo's are nearly full grown with a smaller Aro.
Not always. That said, it can depend on the individual fish, how the arowana was raised and fed, etc., so not exactly disagreeing with you... examples only, not trying to state a cosmic, no exceptions truth here:


 
  • Like
Reactions: Tristan's 6000 Fish
Not always. That said, it can depend on the individual fish, how the arowana was raised and fed, etc., so not exactly disagreeing with you... examples only, not trying to state a cosmic, no exceptions truth here:



I agree. I had a Silver for a few years but had to sell him because he killed everything within the tank... plants, filters, heaters, other fish, my hand, etc.. I had always fed him live fish, which may have been the cause of his idiotic behavior.
 
  • Like
Reactions: neutrino
MonsterFishKeepers.com