Getting Ideas

  • We are currently upgrading MFK. thanks! -neo

kzimmerman

Piranha
MFK Member
Mar 18, 2009
880
211
76
delmar md
So the filter system I'm setting up for my 130g tank is a 75g sump full of anarchis. I was going to hide it under the tank, but then I thought, why?. So, I'm going to make it a display tank as well, and I was going to put some anabantoids in it. Then I remembered how boring they are, and why couldn't I do puffers? They are a particular love of mine.
So I was looking at ideas, I'm looking for smaller, planted tank safe puffers 2-4 max size that will tolerate each other. It is not going to be a high flow tank at all, so stuff like greenbottles are out, as are pea puffers, because you will never see them.
Thoughts?
 
  • Like
Reactions: Deadeye
If it’s functioning as a sump, I probably wouldn’t do a puffer because they are going to make a huge mess.
Amazons are my go to for a puffer that likes company though.
 
It's not exactly a sump in the traditional sense, but rather a very well planted tank with a lot of anarchis to act as a filter. I think it's an underwater equivalent of the plants people have been sticking in their hob for filtration. It's an experiment, really, and the puffers would make a nice addition if the system is viable.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Deadeye
If it’s functioning as a sump, I probably wouldn’t do a puffer because they are going to make a huge mess.
Amazons are my go to for a puffer that likes company though.

Do you think possibly pea puffers could work?
 
I don't think we would ever see them.
 
If not dwarfs, red eyes could work - they are a bit bigger and more visible.
Dwarf puffers can be active and visible, they’re just small. The other problem is how much they hate each other (and yet they school in the wild), I’d think a 75 would make compatibility better.
Really the best puffers to keep together are amazons and schoutodini.
 
  • Like
Reactions: tlindsey
So the plot thickens. My wife has given me the okay to do a plywood tank. I have the front, back and sides from a 125 that a guy broke the bottom out of.. I was going to use two pieces and make a 14' long tank, but that idea was quickly shot down with "kurt, be reasonable." Lol. So the glass is 6 feet long, and I'm aiming for a tank 24-30 inches deep. That means that I might use the 130 for the sump, which gives me more options. I think though, that the amount of fast growing plants that I need to grow in it, I want to limit it to a single puffer that's about 6" or so.
There are some other options too. Like shrimp. keep the sump clean and provide food for the fish.
What's really attractive though.......
Use my 2 empty 75's as sumps for both the plywood and 130,
use hob filters on the 130 and put pothos or something in some of them. Probably old tetra filters that are still running strong after 25 years, and ignore the pile of aquaclears.....That would leave me with 2 75's that could have a puffer or too in it.
I would dearly love to have T. Linneatus again. The first time I had them I was a beginner. This was before the internet, so you had to rely on the LFS guys to find information on them. Consequently, they didn't get any bigger than that, were peaceful community fish and would do fine in a ten gallon tank with my sword fish. So I bought 3. That day I went and bought a 15 for them as they massacred everything else in the tank and were fighting too. Long story short, one died, and the other 2 lived out their days in a divided 55. That was the best I could do for them, and it turned out it didn't really matter, as a house fire took them out. And I do have 2 pieces of glass.....
So, if I get a couple fahakas and put them in the 130, and given good care, how fast would they grow to about 10"? That's the biggest size I'm willing to keep in an 18" tank.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Deadeye
I’m pretty sure fahaka have an inch per month growth rate.
 
  • Like
Reactions: tlindsey
What size does their growth start slowing down?
 
What size does their growth start slowing down?
Not sure. Haven’t kept one but I think it’s pretty constant.
FahakaPapa FahakaPapa Fat Homer Fat Homer
 
MonsterFishKeepers.com