Goldfish foods?

  • We are currently upgrading MFK. thanks! -neo

Cohazard

Arapaima
MFK Member
Jul 13, 2005
8,985
2,045
203
So I'm finally setting up a tank dedicated only to fancy goldfish.

Just wondering what other fancy goldfish keepers feed to their fish?

I've got three types of Hikari goldfish pellets in the mail, but what else can I supplement that with?

Any frozen foods okay?

Thanks for the help :)
 
I don't own goldfish, but I know Omega One makes great fish food, both in flake and pellet form. I feed my Bettas Omega One Super Color Flakes for tropical fish. My Green Sunfish seems to take a liking to them too which is interesting because it wouldn't eat any other kind of flake/pellet food, but it'll eat the Omega One flakes the moment it hits water. Omega One also makes fish food specifically for Goldfish as well.

The other reason why I'd say to go for this brand is because they use whole fish instead of fish meal. It's texture is different from other fish flakes too, so I'd recommend getting Omega One for your fishes. :)
 
What are these pellet products you got, Sergio? What fancy goldfish do you have?

I keep mostly fancy goldfish myself. The first thing we have to remember is most of the fancy goldfish have a very compact appearance which also implies their body organs are greatly compressed as a result of that done by selective breeding. In this case, digestion becomes a little more awkward hence most of the cases involve goldfish suffering from buoyancy issues, bloat or constipation.

In connection to the above paragraph, we need to include a big portion of high fiber in their diet. This can be done by feeding them vegetable matter and extra aquarium plant cuttings which are very high in fiber. If possible, make gel foods and use baby foods that are purely vegetable matter. Be very careful with the ingredients you choose. Some vegetables such as broccolis and brussel sprouts produce gas and those can likely cause buoyancy issues if the goldfish are overfed with those stuff. You could simply stick to pears, collards, dill greens and peas.

A lot of commercial foods have very low fiber. I don't think of all the food products I tried to compile, one ever has the right fiber content. They are mostly focused on protein content unfortunately and while very low fiber content is good for reducing pollution, it discourages the goldfish from expelling the trapped wastes inside their GI (gastrointestinal) tract.

Secondly, a lot of foods contain the rubbish fillers (starch). Starch is also responsible for producing gases inside the GI tract. You must make sure your choice of food does not comprise a bigger portion of starch-based ingredients especially if the top ten slots on the ingredients list contain more than 3 starch-based ingredients with one starch-based ingredient taking up the top spot. I go for food products where the first ingredient should be anything other than a starch-based ingredient.

I feed my own goldfish Hikari Lionhead, homemade gel foods, Mazuri gel foods, aquarium plants, frozen stuffs and many more. What I avoid are freeze-dried stuffs and commercial foods that contain too muc starch. Floating types are also avoided. Pond type goldfish such as shubunkins would not have issues with any of those foods but as fancy ones have a lot of issues compared to the pond types, the problematic ones have to be avoided at all costs to minimize the issues as much as possible.

Assuming your goldfish are still very young, you could aim for at least 40-60% protein content. The Mazuri 5M70 caters to that. Unfortunately, Mazuri gel foods, like other commercial foods, have very low fiber content at 2% so it is best you add vegetable matter in their diet. Adult goldfish will need not more than 30% of the total protein content as it simply adds up only to pollution since they cannot fully utilize the protein for body and wen development.

Lastly, I add acidophilus in my gel food recipes to help cut down the possible gas that may be produce by the goldfish as they eat almost anything. It is available in health stores. It is not a necessity if you are avoiding foods that contain too much starch or are floating types but it can help as a precaution.

Hope this helps.

Lupes
 
Thank you for the great info Lupe! I had read bout the mazuri before when I was trying to setup a goldfish only tank before, but that didn't pan out.

Yes my godlfish are very young, I currently have ryukins, a pearl scale, orandas, shubunkins, and a bubble eye I just got today.

The foods I got are Hikari lionhead, hikari oranda (floating type), and Saki Hikari goldfish color enhancing pellet. I currently have scrap leaves in the tank for them to munch on, not because I knew of the fiber, but just because I knew they like eating plant matter so I wanted to add variety.

I also bought some frozen peas today to aid in their digestion.
 
Yep. The Hikari Oranda Gold is a floating type. Oddly enough, both Oranda Gold and Lionhead seem similar to me with the exception that they are floating and sinking respectively. I feed my goldfish only the sinking types but your shubunkin could do with the floating pellets. Looks like you're on right track so far.:)
 
Yeah I wish I didn't get the oranda food, but I'll just be sure to soak it before feeding.


Any idea on what is the difference between the three colors of saki-hikari goldfish food?
 
I can't find the ingredients list however these are all I could retrieve for comparisons.




Saki-Hikari Fancy Goldfish-Color Enhancing Diet
  1. Rich in highly purified Astaxanthin (a carotenoid) and pure-cultured spirulina, offering lab verified, vivid color-enhancement of the reds without negatively impacting the whites.
  2. A complete and balanced formulation which promotes improved growth and desirable form while offering improved assimilation.
  3. Rich in vitamin E and vitamin C offering superior stress reduction and improved immunity to infectious disease.
  4. The Hikari-Germ(TM) reduces and reconditions waste thereby improving overall water quality, filter effectiveness and regularly scheduled maintenance.
Crude Protein......min. 45%
Crude Fat...........min. 7.0%
Crude Fiber.........max. 3.0%
Moisture.............max. 10%
Crude Ash...........max. 20%
Phosphorus.........min. 1.8%




Saki-Hikari Fancy Goldfish-Basic Diet
  1. A specialized blend of the finest animal and plant proteins, carbohydrates, amino acids and fats offering improved growth and desirable form.
  2. The Hikari-Germ reduces and reconditions waste thereby improving overall water quality, filter effectiveness and helps reduce regularly scheduled maintenance.
  3. Our lab studies have verified the unique ingredient mix improves the brightness of the white part of your fish's body.
  4. Rich in vitamins E and C offer effective stress reduction and improved immunity to infectious disease.
  5. Smaller pellet size allows ready acceptance, even for younger Goldfish.
Crude Protein......min. 45%

Crude Fat...........min. 5.0%
Crude Fiber.........max. 3.0%
Moisture.............max. 10%
Crude Ash...........max. 20%
Phosphorus.........min. 1.8%



Saki-Hikari Fancy Goldfish-Extreme Color Enhancing Diet
  1. Our unique combination of carefully selected color enhancing ingredients including Spirulina, Marigold, Astaxanthin and Phaffia Dried Yeast offers extreme color enhancing capacity not previously available. More rapid color with deeper hues can be expected when compared to other color enhancing foods, even Saki Hikari Goldfish Color Enhancing Diet.
  2. The Hikari-Germ promotes more rapid digestion thereby reducing output while working to decompose waste thereby improving overall water quality, filter effectiveness and helps reduce regularly scheduled maintenance.
  3. Higher levels of vitamin E and C offer active stress reduction and thereby improved immunity to stress induced disease. Our Lab tests verified feeding using as little as 25% Saki-Hikari Fancy Goldfish Extreme Color Enhancing Diet still offers superior color development. Note, exclusive feeding may cause acceptance issues and/or reduced growth due to the focus on color enhancement.
Crude Protein......min. 46%

Crude Fat...........min. 7.0%
Crude Fiber.........max. 2.0%
Moisture.............max. 10%
Crude Ash...........max. 19%
Phosphorus.........min. 1.5%



All three are loaded with a lot of protein which is appropriate for young goldfish, but not adults. Like other commercial foods, the fiber content is still not enough and while it is good for reducing pollution rate, it may still not encourage the fish to flush out its wastes totally out of the system to avoid constipation and bloat. They're all okay to me but you do have to add more fiber to their menu which extra aquarium plant cuttings and vegetable matter can readily cater to particularly peas.

P.S. The red coloration of the fish can always be enhanced much more effectively and cost-efficiently by raising them in shallow ponds exposed to sunlight with green water and oxygen regulated very well. Green water serves as continuous food supply for the fish. You do need to make sure oxygen is maximized because in green water zones, oxygen level is very critical especially during the night wherein respiration takes place and they compete greatly for oxygen especially as both the fish and algae consume a lot of oxygen. The pond will need replenishing most of its green water from time to time. Leave out at least 10-20% of green water to continue seeding the pond with it.
 
awesome thanks! I got the color enhancing one, not the extreme one.

I'm offering peas once a week, should I offer it up more frequently?
 
Definitely. It'll help flush out the excess wastes. You could feed them shrimps, scallops, bloodworms, mosquito larva and chopped earthworms if you haven't yet, Sergio.
 
MonsterFishKeepers.com