Is the tank currently set up using only the one heater? If so does it keep the tank stable at the desired temp?
I use 2W per gallon when keeping a tank 80*F in a room that is no cooler than upper/mid 60s... I've never had an issue keeping the tank temp stable...
When you have to large of a heater the heater turns on/off more frequently, thus wearing out the on/off mechanism, thus allowing the heater to get stuck on and killing the fish...
More is not always better...