There are little things that may contribute:
1. What temp is your home usually at?
2. Do you have glass lids for your 200? I find that those lids can save you a quite a bit of money in regards to heating and maintaining the temp of your aquarium
3. Possibly insignificant, but how are your heaters positioned in your sump?
I have (2) 250W heaters fully submerged in the first chamber of my sump. Water drips through the bio balls and is pulled over the heaters to the pump in the last chamber. I was worried about heating the tank as well, because my pump is rather powerful, but my tank maintains a nice warm temp pretty consistently.
post a pic or two when you get home, and I'm sure it'll get figured out quickly
- John