Hello all - I'm new here and looking for help!

  • We are currently upgrading MFK. thanks! -neo

jasmirnea

Feeder Fish
MFK Member
Jun 6, 2011
6
0
0
Middle-of-Nowhere, ND
I have a natural pond that is not spring fed. The water level right now is over 8 feet at the center. It will fluctuate some, but has not been less than 4 feet and does not freeze solid in the winter. I do not have filtration, although the pond contains natural vegetation. I currently have minnows and goldfish stocked. Naturally there are frogs and snails.

I want to know what kind of fish will live well in the pond. It is around a half an acre in size. The banks are sloped all the way around, but even out for a pretty level, although muddy, bottom. There are three small islands where ducks have nested in the past. I keep Pekin ducks, but the wild ones (Mallards, etc...) utilize it as well. Currently the water is high enough that the islands are barely visible, but that should receded some in the next month or so, depending on rain levels.

I believe the pond originated as a very large man-made watering hole many decades ago.

I would like to stock the pond with fish like bass or trout, but am not sure if that is wise. The minnows are breeding and the goldfish, when I happen to see them, are growing. I do not feed them and all seems well.

My greatest concern is circulation/aeration, I guess. Is it needed? Is a windmill sufficient aeration is needed? Last winter was the first time I stocked the pond and this spring there was significant winter kill. I am assuming that was due to no gas exchange as the surface froze. Prior to freezing, the minnow and red rosie population was drastically increasing. This spring, as mentioned earlier, I restocked the minnows and went with goldfish instead of rosies.

Thanks!
 
very nice. id stock with bass. unless you have lots of flow for the trout id go with both then. trout need a contant flow over there gills to breath their like sharks in a way. If you dont mind feeding pellets you could do sturgeon and koi. alot of them it seems in your pond. stugeon get from anywhere to 4'-8' or a white sturgeon that gets to 12' but thats wild ones though so it would be very much smaller most likely in captivity. you can feed the koi , koi pellets and the sturgeon eat that to. they both eat carbs thats what there pellets consist of. or better yet u can mix both koi pellet with sturgeon pellet. but imo sturgeon food is expensive. goodluck
 
stugeon can get far bigger then that Z... Koi would be what i would try get them now by end of the year they could be an easy 12 inch just keep a hole thawed in the ice and you should be good.
 
Thanks for the responses 'Z' and 'dzjr.' I would ideally like to have something I can enjoy, like bass, but since I have no current running through it, was wondering if that would be a problem. As you can see from the pics, the wind blows across it easily and even makes white caps at times, but I am not sure that would suffice. I am sure I would do fine with Koi, but I would rarely see them due to the size of the water. Is there some place I can go to see my options for fish species in my situation?

P.S. I LOVE this site! I'm glad I happened across it!
 
yes there is the coldwater secion. i could post a link to if you'd like. site has a new layout not digging it... For the koi you'd be surprised. i bought lil 2inchers NEVER saw them. but i saw there buddies about 12inches they would come out to feed. now since they know i feed them they all come up to me and beg even(even the 2inchers!) when am inside cleaning the pond they follow you around pretty neat.

and dz i was refering to smaller species. Stuegeon do get really big. there once was a sturgeon seen from a helicopter it was 20feet ATLEAST they said. it was a river monster episode. they didnt prove it 100% but it was 20ft and had an exact outline of one.
 
stugeon can get far bigger then that Z... Koi would be what i would try get them now by end of the year they could be an easy 12 inch just keep a hole thawed in the ice and you should be good.
depend on how you feed the koi, they can easy get pass 12 inches in 6 month!
if you want to go fishing sometime, get some bass, trout and catfish!
if you want to just have some nice big fish in there, you can add koi, sturgeon!
 
Thanks, HungDang - I would love to have fishable fish; does it make a difference if my pond is not spring fed? I don't have a continuous flow of water to create current. Bass and catfish would be fun! I'm pretty sure the trout need a fast water supply. How about for aeration? Is that necessary in a body of water my size? What else should I consider? I am excited to get more than minnows and goldfish. Thanks!
 
MonsterFishKeepers.com