Help please, major aggression problem

  • We are currently upgrading MFK. thanks! -neo

pelleeklund

Peacock Bass
MFK Member
May 23, 2009
1,494
425
122
Pennsylvania
I had posted a question about a week ago but for the last few days I have had some bad developments I could use some help with. Basically I have only two fish in my 220, a 10 in. male dempsey and a 6 in. female dovii. Recently the both of them have been displaying what I assume is breeding behavior, the male shaking, lip locking and ultimately the female laying eggs. Nothing has come of their attempts, but it has had me cleaning the tank more often when the eggs go bad. Anyway after the last cleaning I noticed that the tank was a bit colder than I had wanted it, I'm thinking one of my heaters took a crap, so I added another heater and have the tank going at about 78 degrees. Since that day I noticed that the dempsey has become ferocious with the dovii. He wont let her move without hammering her, so basically she has spent the last few days hiding as best as she can. Im not exactly sure what the issue is here but my obvious guess would be the temperature change has the dempsey acting up. Ive heard the heat increase will increase metabolism and aggression but he seems uncharacteristically fired up. I lowered the heater and dropped the tank down to the low 70's last night, assuming it would help, but when I got home from work today it was the same story, dovii hiding while the dempsey stayed on patrol. My only other guess is that she's holding out on him, which I would assume would provoke aggression, but I cant make her give it up to test my theory. If anyone can help I shed some light on the possible reasons why my dempsey has got the bloodlust I would very much appreciate it. I would hate to lose my dovii if there is something I can do to help.
 
Any recommendations for a hardy dither fish? I tried adding a couple 5in. Jags a few weeks back and they demolished them. Ever since they paired off they have been pretty ignorant about tank mates. By the way all of this mating business has me wondering if they will ever successfully produce fry. Any ideas? It was never my intention but I wouldn't mind. By the way I wouldn't be putting any of them in to the fish trade, I know the reprocussions and I have plans in place to handle the bunch.
 
big tinfoil barbs maybe? Otherwise I'd say you're best to divide the tank or get rid of one or the other fish...
 
you could get 5-6 silver dollars they are hardy and very fast. you could also get tiger barbs if you could find them large enuff, my dad has those with his red devil and they are just too fast :) if you added other cichlids they would have to be large already, and to add to that a jack dempsey and dovii are about as mean as they come - that being said there isn't a whole lot you could do other than a tank divider.
 
I use tiger barbs with my sa/ca cichlids. Still didn't keep my JD from killing a good sized jewel cichlid. Might have to separate them. A 10" jack can be a handful once they decide to dominate a tank.

Larger tiger barbs can make good dithers because they are really rough and tough and lightening quick. For the most part, it works for me. Not exactly geographically correct, but whatever works
 
Good ideas. Little and quick hadn't even crossed my mind. I'm definitely going to check out my options. Anyone have any idea if these two will ever successfully produce fry? I'm still curious if it will work. If it's never going to happen it might be a deal-breaker. I couldn't keep cleaning the mess that comes from the unsuccessful attempts. They always seem to wait until right after I clean the tank to give it a go too. Two cleanings in a week cuts into my fishing time.
 
cory just recently wrote an article about white cloud minnows.
Small fast cheap schooling fish.
I believe the link in the general discussion..
Anyway, I plan to add a bunch to my 220 just incase anyone feels particularly agressive one day.
That could be an option, especially how if they are as cheap as he says, 10c ents is just a drop in the hat.
 
MonsterFishKeepers.com