I have two JBJ reaction filters on my planted discus tank, I haven't noticed any difference when the sterilizers are on or off. The main reasons I know of for them is to fight algae blooms, and stoping the spreading of diseases. I honestly don't see how that claim would make any sense. That would be like saying don't keep your fish in perfect water because when you put them in poor quality water they will die. Your water quality should always be good, the fact you preventing the spread of disease should not have effect on your fish's capability to fight disease.