Hikari - the blue and the red - an FYI

  • We are currently upgrading MFK. thanks! -neo

TrikkyMakk

Fire Eel
MFK Member
Feb 3, 2008
1,580
2
68
Tampa, Florida
Just an FYI. I was at Petsmart (yea I know but it was convenient at the moment) yesterday and I needed some more Hikari Gold. Well they have it in the normal red package I buy and then I noticed a blue package that I hadn't seen before. I compared the ingredients and descriptions and they were pretty much the same. The main difference from what I could tell was the red I usually buy had 2oz of pellets while the blue had 3.5oz (and costs just 2 dollars more). So I thought wow, almost double the pellets for only two dollars more.

Anyhoo, I asked the Petsmart employee (of whom had been pointed out to me to be a wizard at this sort of information) what the difference between the two was because I couldn't see it from the packaging. He said that Hikari likes to change the colors of their packaging from time to time, mentioning that they used to have a white package too at some point. It was all a merketing ploy according to him.

Turns out that the blue one has sinking pellets in it (I don't see Hikari mentioning that on the package or I missed it). I imagine the clever white packages he was referring to is the algae wafers.

So just as an FYI, stick to the red unless you are feeding earth eaters or something like that. I ended up buying the red ones later on at Walmart.
 
I buy all my food online. It's still less than half the price of lfs even with shipping.

Drs Foster and Smith has Hikari Massivore 13.4 oz for $18.69 on sale right now. My lfs wants $44.99 for the same bag.
 
I had alot of trouble finding sinking pellets before I figured out the color scheme too. They're not really labeled too clearly.
 
buy all your Hikari products from our member Johnptc...........by the kilo
 
I actually like the sinking version for all of my cichlids. It makes them forage around to find it rather than slapping the water surface and causing a big mess. :-)
 
on the blue pack, at the bottom of the gold strip at the side it has a little pic saying "sinking type".
 
Yes I get all or my Hikari online as well.

As far as Hikari changing colors of the packages that is BS. They been the same color package as far as I can remember.
 
Natalie;2867962; said:
I actually like the sinking version for all of my cichlids. It makes them forage around to find it rather than slapping the water surface and causing a big mess. :-)

That is an interesting concept. I don't plan on letting it go to waste but I currently I like the floating because 1) it is easier to remove if they don't eat it all and sometimes my fish are not as hungry and 2) i can more easily see if they have eaten it all. once I go through this bag I will have to see about this idea.
 
cichlid2006;2868140; said:
on the blue pack, at the bottom of the gold strip at the side it has a little pic saying "sinking type".

It must be real little. I will check it out tonight. Thanks for pointing that out.
 
MonsterFishKeepers.com