How many animals is too many animals?

  • We are currently upgrading MFK. thanks! -neo

Oompa Loompa

Polypterus
MFK Member
Feb 6, 2016
808
318
87
How many do you think is too many? Obviously, the rule is that once it feels like a job versus enjoyment to take care of them, it's too much. But what's your magic number. On the thread "how many animals do you have", I said that I wanted to have somewhere around tens of thousands of gallons of tanks, along with tons of reptiles and birds. I have since downsized, as that many tanks would be a ton of work. My new list would all be in one room, after I move in on my own, and all the applicable ones will be tied together (within, say, 50 gallons of each other) and the ones that can't be tied together will be hooked up to a sump to make water changes as easy as possible. My list is now:
-1,200 gallon ply tank, housing amazon/SA/CA monsters
-65 gallon planted tank
-55 gallon brackish tank
-55 gallon FOWLR
-150 gallon reef (entirely zoas and palys, possibly LPS as well though)
-Rack of 6 20 gallon planted tanks
-180 gallon low-tech planted
-180 gallon bichir tank
-210 gallon bichir tank
-900 gallon FW ray tank
-29 gallon (biocube, likely) reef
-125 gallon FOWLR
-300 gallon FOWLR
-300 gallon puffer tank
-400 gallon turtle tank
-65 gallon reef
-20 gallon planted
-150 gallon planted
Potentially two stock tanks, both 8' in diameter, tied in together housing benthic sharks, no larger than that though
Reptiles would consist of a large wall of wooden cages (24 in total, focusing on a collection of mostly insectivorous medium-large lizards), a few medium glass tanks (from 30 to 65 gallons), a few 10 and 20 gallons, and then a rack of 10 18" exo terras for PDFs.

Sounds like a lot, gallonage in the fish room would be 6,000 gallons. This may seem like a lot however this is the sump size of some people's tanks on here. Does this seem like too much to you?

If you had the money for whatever collection you wanted? How much would you get?
 
If I had the money none, I would be to busy working and traveling to be keeping animals.

 
I recently decided that three tanks is too many so I'd probably only keep one. A 125 with a ram pair and a large school of dithers.
 
  • Like
Reactions: convict360
I have 6 running currently. Smallest is 100 gallons. That's enough for an old guy. Been doing this since 1970.
 
If I had the money none, I would be to busy working and traveling to be keeping animals.

Fair enough, I'm too obsessed with aquariums and reptiles to not have any though. Lol that song is my ringtone ;)
I recently decided that three tanks is too many so I'd probably only keep one. A 125 with a ram pair and a large school of dithers.
I guess for some people, one tank is enough. Not me though ;)
I have 6 running currently. Smallest is 100 gallons. That's enough for an old guy. Been doing this since 1970.
That seems like a good amount. How big's your largest?

6,000 seems huge if you go onto any other forum, but you come on here and some people won't bat an eye. Unless it's all in one tank - that's a different story. Arapaimag's sump is probably bigger than 6,000 gallons, lol! I think in my dream room, it's like 4k gallons of freshwater and 2k of salt (1.5k in catshark/epaulette shark ponds).
 
I got one tank and it's all I want. To many other happenings going on in my life. You and ocean railroad should go in on a place together.
 
I currently have 6 tanks running, plans to set up 2 or 3 more and have 3 reptiles with plans of 1 or 2 more. My comfort level: can everything still be maintained if I get sick/disabled or lose my job. I travel allot for work and if my current tanks can't be maintained for a week or two by my wife, I have too many tanks. I also design filtration systems and everything with the intent to neglect the system if for some reason I can't maintain them for a few weeks.
 
MonsterFishKeepers.com