i need help with a moderate size-growing pleco for my algae!

  • We are currently upgrading MFK. thanks! -neo

insanity0x1

Feeder Fish
MFK Member
Nov 4, 2010
329
0
0
moundsville, WV
I have a HUGE brown algae problem, so far im just scrubbin and water changing and its "helping" but not irradicating. ive herd the algae eaters do pretty well.. i have a 125 gal with (juvies) oscar, 2 JD's, BP and a severum. im looking for one that gets around 8 inches or so? or a reasonable size! thanks for the help :)
 
What are your water parameters? I think your problem is high nitrates. Getting a pleco wont help that. he will only create more poo and thus more nitrates.
 
gah i knew it! i dont have any check kits ATM, i was thinking high nitrates as well but was unsure completely, ill have to see if i can get a kit and probably some nitrate remover..wait i may have some down stairs..that amiquel plus (spelling?) ive had good exp with that previously.. i dont know if it will help but ill try that (as its used for all parimiter reducers supposibly ) so ill update after a few days of that? :)
 
The only way to remove nitrates quickly without adding chemical is to just do larger water changes. I would not recommend adding any pleco or catfish as that will just add more nitrates. I would change out all the water over the coarse of a week while scrubbing down all the algae in the tank. If you have your lights on for long periods of time as well, I would cut back the hours they are on. I had the same problem you have and found that to be the best way to treat a algae bloom- cutting back on the light hours and upping the water changes. I run my lights no more than 7 hours a day and do 50% water changes once a week and it has kept everything in check. Also, be sure to wash out your mechanical media (sponge) in your filters. You should start to see a real difference after the first week. This method is much safer and more successful than adding any chemicals to your tank water.
 
Cookie*420;4818019; said:
The only way to remove nitrates quickly without adding chemical is to just do larger water changes. I would not recommend adding any pleco or catfish as that will just add more nitrates. I would change out all the water over the coarse of a week while scrubbing down all the algae in the tank. If you have your lights on for long periods of time as well, I would cut back the hours they are on. I had the same problem you have and found that to be the best way to treat a algae bloom- cutting back on the light hours and upping the water changes. I run my lights no more than 7 hours a day and do 50% water changes once a week and it has kept everything in check. Also, be sure to wash out your mechanical media (sponge) in your filters. You should start to see a real difference after the first week. This method is much safer and more successful than adding any chemicals to your tank water.
:grinno: thank you. i sound stupid now, but thats again, what i was thinking!.. i figured my lights being a lower temp, would allow a little longer on time, but i didnt look at the picture of on at 6:15 am, off at 11:18pm :screwy: ill definitely cut back and will probably be kicking myself for not doing so:naughty: and i do a 25% wc every sunday religiously, and at the moment am doing about 30%, and will shorten lights. reason being theyre on for so long is because i have to get ready and feed them and they are...lazy when the lights first turn on, and at evenings im busy, so it was convienent, but i guess adding a break in the timer would do it! :wall:
thanks for your advice guys!
 
Please....there is nothing stupid about that. Sometimes the obvious is the least obvious, I made the very same mistake and had the lights on for 13 hours a day and was changing 25% water once a week. Once you get the light and water change schedule dialed in, you should have no problems. I do still get algae, but only enough that it needs to be scraped off the glass every other week. And whatever algae is growing on rocks and stuff has not gotten out of control but actually looks good in my opinion.

Not sure what to do about your feeding schedule if you leave that early for work and wanna do a morning feed. Myself, I don't like to turn on the lights before they come on themselves with the timer. I have some blue led lights I bought at Pep Boys and wired up to a 12v adapter for moonlights (you can find these cheaper at a computer parts store FYI). Early in the morning when I feed my fish with only the moonlights on, the fish can see the larger food I feed them (peas, algae tabs, crickets), just not the small pellets. Just shooting an idea at you if you wanna try it. It works for me, I drop my Chocolate cichlid food midnight snacks under the led moonlights all the time. Best of luck!
 
Cookie*420;4818128; said:
Please....there is nothing stupid about that. Sometimes the obvious is the least obvious, I made the very same mistake and had the lights on for 13 hours a day and was changing 25% water once a week. Once you get the light and water change schedule dialed in, you should have no problems. I do still get algae, but only enough that it needs to be scraped off the glass every other week. And whatever algae is growing on rocks and stuff has not gotten out of control but actually looks good in my opinion.

Not sure what to do about your feeding schedule if you leave that early for work and wanna do a morning feed. Myself, I don't like to turn on the lights before they come on themselves with the timer. I have some blue led lights I bought at Pep Boys and wired up to a 12v adapter for moonlights (you can find these cheaper at a computer parts store FYI). Early in the morning when I feed my fish with only the moonlights on, the fish can see the larger food I feed them (peas, algae tabs, crickets), just not the small pellets. Just shooting an idea at you if you wanna try it. It works for me, I drop my Chocolate cichlid food midnight snacks under the led moonlights all the time. Best of luck!
yea, ive been concidering some type of moonlighting, but has been put on hold with my other hobby, guitars:naughty: but on the to do list. as far as feeding, i have to wake up at 6 for school, feed them some flakes, get home around 4, get drawn into the computer..MFK.. :naughty: then that was at 11PM i fed them flakes and black worms, so i just feed twice daily, lightly except for the worms..they love em! i always give in ^_^ but yea ive got W/C's and will have the lighting tuned back and should be good to go! thanks for the appreciated imput!
 
Another option is to give your tank a "siesta" and turn the lights off during the middle of the day, when you are away at work. The fish don't mind.
 
I agree with all of the above. The addition of any pleco will increase your nitrate levels alot... pooping machines, and that goes for all of them....

That being said, I collect plecos and the best algae eater I've ever run across is the L052... gets about 6" long and never stops eating Algea. Loves all vegetables as well. Won't touch a sinking pellet or bloodworm. Got mine for about $20. Very beautiful fish against darker backgrounds....

Did I mention they never stop eating algae?
 
MonsterFishKeepers.com