ID on 2 different ATF's please

  • We are currently upgrading MFK. thanks! -neo

SSJ Crit

Black Skirt Tetra
MFK Member
Sep 27, 2018
42
14
13
40
Could some of you guys out there with the trained eyes give a guess as to what species these two different ATF's are?

Screenshot_2018-10-01-22-38-14.png received_475752776265971.jpeg
 
First one is gatf and second looks like a fatf. Not 100% on the fatf though. Great find!
 
Agree with the first being GATF.

The second one is tricky for me as to tell VATF, BATF, TATF, etc. apart I'd need to sweat over the ID sticky by C Chicxulub .

BTW, the whole taxonomy of the colorful ATF (that is non-GATF) needs much work and according to our resident experts Wes and Chicx we may be getting the colorfull species all wrong anyway.

So I don't even wanna try anymore.

**********************************************

Sister threads for cross-linking:

https://www.monsterfishkeepers.com/forums/threads/thoughts-on-my-3-atf-situation.709080/

https://www.monsterfishkeepers.com/...d-my-atf-in-mail-need-id-please.709000/page-2
 
Agree with the first being GATF.

The second one is tricky for me as to tell VATF, BATF, TATF, etc. apart I'd need to sweat over the ID sticky by C Chicxulub .

BTW, the whole taxonomy of the colorful ATF (that is non-GATF) needs much work and according to our resident experts Wes and Chicx we may be getting the colorfull species all wrong anyway.

So I don't even wanna try anymore.

**********************************************

Sister threads for cross-linking:

https://www.monsterfishkeepers.com/forums/threads/thoughts-on-my-3-atf-situation.709080/

https://www.monsterfishkeepers.com/...d-my-atf-in-mail-need-id-please.709000/page-2

Yea that makes sense that the colored ATF species is going to need new information in light of all the recent data everyone has observed.

I definitely feel confident in identifying GATF now. It's just the other species that are hard to identify. Its also amazing how a lot of new information has come up with the five species further making it more possible for variations of each of the species.
 
  • Like
Reactions: thebiggerthebetter
MonsterFishKeepers.com