Id this fish for me please

  • We are currently upgrading MFK. thanks! -neo
Maybe some roundness in the middle of the bar but I’d guess guinacara dacrya maybe.
 
  • Like
Reactions: tlindsey
Thanks guys normally wouldn't buy a fish before researching but impulse buys get to you. Anyone have personal experience with them?
 
The photo I posted was of mine, I worked with them for about 5 years.
I started with 20 juvies (@1") bought from a breeder in Chicago, first put in a 75 gallon tank to grow out.
They started spawning about 2.5" , and their eggs are deep green in color, and were (at that point) moved to a 150 gal.
They are omnivores so a pellet containing a high Spirulina algae content was used

kept in a S American community cichlid tank with pike cichlids, and Acarichthys heckelli. Took them about 2 years to reach @5".

They are a shoaling species, and were never aggressive as a group in my tank, except with each other during the spawning rut, and when defending a spawning site, even then hardly aggressive compared to say....any Central American cichlids

In nature they appear in clear water and black water habitats, so I would occasionally use black water (achieved by soaking leaf litter) to imitate seasonal changes they might experience in nature (rainy season/dry season) the black, softer water seemed to initiate spawning .
My tap water pH averaged 7.8 so it was a little on the high side for them, and alkaline, so rain water was combined to my tap water to dilute the higher pH and mineral content.
 
The photo I posted was of mine, I worked with them for about 5 years.
I started with 20 juvies (@1") bought from a breeder in Chicago, first put in a 75 gallon tank to grow out.
They started spawning about 2.5" , and their eggs are deep green in color, and were (at that point) moved to a 150 gal.
They are omnivores so a pellet containing a high Spirulina algae content was used

kept in a S American community cichlid tank with pike cichlids, and Acarichthys heckelli. Took them about 2 years to reach @5".

They are a shoaling species, and were never aggressive as a group in my tank, except with each other during the spawning rut, and when defending a spawning site, even then hardly aggressive compared to say....any Central American cichlids

In nature they appear in clear water and black water habitats, so I would occasionally use black water (achieved by soaking leaf litter) to imitate seasonal changes they might experience in nature (rainy season/dry season) the black, softer water seemed to initiate spawning .
My tap water pH averaged 7.8 so it was a little on the high side for them, and alkaline, so rain water was combined to my tap water to dilute the higher pH and mineral content.

Thank you for the info and pictures. I added 4 of these with 3 Geos Alts, 3 Bolivian rams, 3 gold rams, and a Electric Blue Acara. All around 1-2 inches in a 75g tank. Will upgrade in a year to larger tank of course.

Good dither fish for these guys? Tetras?
 
Its funny, I never quite figured out which species I had (tho they were sold to me as G geayii.
They were very chameleon like, in that in the course of a few hours or even minutes could change markings, and color.
Here's what I mean, all same species, from the original group.



 
  • Like
Reactions: fishhead0103666
Great pics. How many do you have? I've been noticing a slight pecking order between the four. Surprisingly the Bolivian Rams are the aggressors in the tank.
 
MonsterFishKeepers.com