Identify my Piranha. Picts.

  • We are currently upgrading MFK. thanks! -neo

Armand

Feeder Fish
MFK Member
Jan 24, 2009
1,773
4
0
Mexico City.
www.piranha-fury.com
Hi guys, I am new here, and I want to show you some picts of my reds.

Sorry because the sharpness in the picts is not good but it is the best I can do with that camera of my wife.

Now the question:

What kind of reds dou you think they are, tank bred or wild caught?



jfkoap.jpg


2q2qpz5.jpg


zn6hkg.jpg


312iskp.jpg


2rpb7sl.jpg
 
Very nice color on your reds! Did you buy these online or lfs?
Hard to say on wild or not,..they look very well cared for thou,..
May want to ask the person you purchased these from,..
 
Impossible to tell in most cases. More likely captive bred than wild caught.

Awesome looking reds though
 
I dont think it really matters, and I would never believe someone saying theyre wild caught anyways.

Those are some very attractive fish, looks like you know what you are doing.
 
Thanks to all of you folks.

Actually they are supposed to be tank bred but someone in other forum told me they looked wild caught.

Despite what some people says I find almost impossible to stablish a difference between wild and tank raised.


Cheers.:headbang2
 
some research showed that the redish eyes of the natts is very not often observed in the wild. the red of the eyes comes from the fact that they have, when raised in tanks, clear eyes and we actually see the color of blood running through their eyes; it is not the actual color of their eyes (as opposed to s. rhombeus or elong) but just the fact that they're clear. in nature, since the water is so cloudy and full of small parts floating, they develop a sort of extra layer over the eye that makes it less transparent. that would explain why caribe and piraya have white eyes, because they can't breed in aquariums and are therefore all wild caught (except some rare caribe breeding ponds in the south).

just a piece of info here, but your natts seem to have white eyes and a particularly developped lower jaw. don't forget that natteris are found all over the amazon river, and therefore are not exactly the same all over the river. just think of s.rhombeus that has so many differences going from one region to another.

i'm not saying that they're wild caught, but i'm saying that we shouldn't take for granted that they're not.

my bet would be that they are, but it is sometginf EXTREMELY hard to say. botomline, you have nice looking Ps bro, thats all that matters!

aight peace
 
leg89;2787018; said:
some research showed that the redish eyes of the natts is very not often observed in the wild. the red of the eyes comes from the fact that they have, when raised in tanks, clear eyes and we actually see the color of blood running through their eyes; it is not the actual color of their eyes (as opposed to s. rhombeus or elong) but just the fact that they're clear. in nature, since the water is so cloudy and full of small parts floating, they develop a sort of extra layer over the eye that makes it less transparent. that would explain why caribe and piraya have white eyes, because they can't breed in aquariums and are therefore all wild caught (except some rare caribe breeding ponds in the south).

just a piece of info here, but your natts seem to have white eyes and a particularly developped lower jaw. don't forget that natteris are found all over the amazon river, and therefore are not exactly the same all over the river. just think of s.rhombeus that has so many differences going from one region to another.

i'm not saying that they're wild caught, but i'm saying that we shouldn't take for granted that they're not.

my bet would be that they are, but it is sometginf EXTREMELY hard to say. botomline, you have nice looking Ps bro, thats all that matters!

aight peace

Thanks bro.

Actually I was thinking about that thing of their lower jaw aswell:

2mo757t.jpg




21mzolg.jpg
 
MonsterFishKeepers.com