Im Back!

  • We are currently upgrading MFK. thanks! -neo

JIENKINZ

Feeder Fish
MFK Member
Mar 18, 2010
316
0
0
New York
Hey everyone! I havent been here for a good 1/2 year cause my old computer broke.... so Id like to share my new plans with ya!
Tank: 250 gallon I think, 72x30x30
Stock:
1x Florida gar
3x Datnoid
1x Tire Track eel
1x clown knife

Maybes that I need suggestions with
1x some kind of arowana?
1x some kind of stingray?
1x zebra shovelnose catfish (Merodontotus tigrinus)
 
no ray with the gar(can be ok but its an iffy combo)
no arrow with gar(again can be iffy but is highly suggested against)
no catfish with gar
 
Lep is right but as he hints those combinations can be done... I suggest visiting the species sub-forums and finding threads with any combos you have in mind and reading as many outcomes as possible.

Personally I have done all three of those to various degrees of success...

Gars w/ Rays: Compatibility is fine, but the gars sometimes go after food the ray has and end up nipping the rays disc. This can end up in slight damage to the ray as well as stress. The worst case scenario is the gar being stung, but I have never seen this occur.

Gars w/ Arowana: This is a more common combination. I find if you put a lot of effort into timing the growth rates you can keep these fish together with minimal aggression. Silver arowana's can be more aggressive than blacks. Problems may arise during feeding when the arowana tries taking food from the gar resulting in snout damage or a very skittish gar that may end up crashing into the glass and breaking its spine. A very iffy combination, just as Lep said.

Gars w/ Catfish: Depends entirely on the catfish, to the point that there's really not even much to say. I've kept big pims with gar before and had no issues, but bigger cats like RTC would likely pose a problem to the gar.

--

So realize anything is sort of a risk, but can be done if enough preparation is done.
 
Lepisosteus platyrhincus;4267002; said:
no ray with the gar(can be ok but its an iffy combo)
no arrow with gar(again can be iffy but is highly suggested against)
no catfish with gar
I've had tsn, rtc, marbled pim, oxydoras niger, plecos, rapheal cats all with gars with no problems.
 
just because u did it doesnt change the fact that this is highly recommend against. how long did u do it? sizes? speices of gar? so many factors go into keeping these together.
 
I did it for about 2-3 months.Gar was 12'', cats about 5-6''. The gars were florida and alligator.
 
So, I wouldn't be too depressed if I couldnt put a stingray or catfish in. What if the florida gar is a little bigger than the leichardti? I really like both of these fish. I guess I thought I just could because Ive seen so many pics with both.....
 
So heres what im thinking then because that messed me up a little
1x tire track eel
1x clown knife
2x ornate bichir
1x saddled bichir
1x Florida Gar
1x leicharti arowana
3x datniods
 
MonsterFishKeepers.com