This is young male Andinoacara coerleopunctatus, note the red seam beginning to show on the caudal, and white seam starting on the dorsal.
I wouldn't jump to any conclusions just yet, yours looks quite small
At a young age all Andinoacara look very similar, so of course it could have been easily mixed up, especially if its from a run of the mill LFS.
below a young female A. coerleopunctatus.