Is this what I think it is? (lots of pics!)

  • We are currently upgrading MFK. thanks! -neo

Oblong Cheese

Feeder Fish
MFK Member
Apr 26, 2011
5
0
0
Australia
Hi all,

First post on these forums. I am glad you guys have a dedicated knife fish section!

I came here because I was looking for information on BGK fry. I have two BGK which I bought from a friend of a friend recently (very cheaply) and have kept for the last 3-4 months in a 5x2x2 foot tank with some other tropical fish. Until I saw this I never really even wondered what sex my fish were (note: gravel is about 5-10mm)


IMG_5307 by thejimmydimple, on Flickr


IMG_5308 by thejimmydimple, on Flickr


IMG_5306 by thejimmydimple, on Flickr


IMG_5305 by thejimmydimple, on Flickr

The other fish in my tank (of which there are more than one) are: neon tetra, blue tetra, rummynose tetra, scissortail rasbora.

Here's a picture of what I believe is my female BGK:

Apteronotus albifrons (black ghost knife fish) by thejimmydimple, on Flickr

Which can be identified by the slight potbelly and shorter, more triangular face. Unfortunately I don't have any good photo of my male BGK as he is much more timid and hides nearly all the time, but I do have two OK photos:


Apteronotus albifrons (black ghost knife fish) by thejimmydimple, on Flickr


Apteronotus albifrons (black ghost knife fish) by thejimmydimple, on Flickr

Until I took the photos above I had never really read into BGK breeding. When I saw them I read mostly that it was nigh-on impossible to breed BGK in a typical aquarium so I am sceptical about it, and given especially that I was never trying to breed them, I am doubtful. But then again, a look at the first picture of the fry above - the shape of the tail and head, and the little beady eye - what else could it be?

I only discovered these (three I saw definitely) when doing a complete rescape of my tank and stirring all the gravel up. They were quite strong swimmers, able to (just) push against the current in the tank, but as soon as I uncovered one it would immediately dive down into a crevice in the gravel and hide itself as you see above.

Since I took these photos I haven't seen them again, so hopefully they are OK and hidden somewhere.
 
It does happen from time-to-time, and it would appear as if you are right with your beliefs, the first does look like the a female, 2nd male.
I've never seen a BGK fry at such a size, however it looks like it based on the shape and eye. It doesn't appear to have a dorsal fin either, so it's more than likely to be a BGK. Very nice. :D
 
Sweet! can't wait to see update on the Fry. :D
 
MonsterFishKeepers.com