Jag Cichlids vs E. Yellows + Ahli

  • We are currently upgrading MFK. thanks! -neo

AquariumLover

Feeder Fish
MFK Member
Oct 25, 2007
406
0
0
Chula Vista, Ca
i realize that i have been posting a lot of completely different threads, and this one tops them all, but i am just not sure on how i want to stock my 75 gal yet. i know for sure that i want to have 1 M/4 F Socolofi, but other than that i am trying to decide between 1 Ahli and 1 M/4 F E. Yellows, or 1 Jag Cichlid. so first of all: will the socolofi survive with the jag? and can a jag survive in a 75 gal tank?
 
AquariumLover;1266410; said:
i realize that i have been posting a lot of completely different threads, and this one tops them all, but i am just not sure on how i want to stock my 75 gal yet. i know for sure that i want to have 1 M/4 F Socolofi, but other than that i am trying to decide between 1 Ahli and 1 M/4 F E. Yellows, or 1 Jag Cichlid. so first of all: will the socolofi survive with the jag? and can a jag survive in a 75 gal tank?
No africans with the Jag. 75 is okay for one Jag. Go with the Africans.
 
tarheels910;1267934; said:
No africans with the Jag. 75 is okay for one Jag. Go with the Africans.

at this action, they sold off 4 ahli fry for $9. i wanted to get it, but i figured my tank couldn't handle it. right? anyways, if i cut back on the number of socolofi and instead of 8 labs i get 5, would i be able to have an ahli pair? and since the 29 gal would be empty after this transition, would it be able to support my little brother's albino oscar? i heard that sometimes fish are able to grow to their surrounding tank size, so i was just hoping that i wouldn't have to put it into my 75 gal. (even if it can't, i will just return the oscar to the store) but like if it can, i know that would make my little brother happy.
 
AquariumLover;1278924; said:
and since the 29 gal would be empty after this transition, would it be able to support my little brother's albino oscar?

How large is the Oscar? If the Oscar is very small, then it would be ok for a little while.
 
No the 29 could not house the oscar. Maybe for a month if it is small. No pair of Ahlis. They will most likely pick off your other fish. Also, it is very hard to find females. I have 2. :) Besides the male would pick on the female. That is why it is suggest to keep 3-4 females per male.
 
I would say it depends whether you want beauty or aggression. First off, keep South/Central americans seperate from Africans. If you are considering Jags, definately look for a larger tank. Male Jags average 21-24" in captivity and the females about 18". Aswell, they are very territorial and will battle for dominance.
 
skateboardmuseum;1283315; said:
I would say it depends whether you want beauty or aggression. First off, keep South/Central americans seperate from Africans. If you are considering Jags, definately look for a larger tank. Male Jags average 21-24" in captivity and the females about 18". Aswell, they are very territorial and will battle for dominance.


I agree with the first statements but those Jag sizes are exagerated. A male will usually max out about 15-18" in captivity and a female more like 12-13" or so.
 
MonsterFishKeepers.com