JAGUAR AND CUBAN CICHLID TANKMATES

  • We are currently upgrading MFK. thanks! -neo
I would not.
The reason being they are so similar, that they would either see each other as competitors, and try to kill each other, or in the case of male females, breed and produce mutts.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Toiletcar
I tried it with no luck. Jag killed the cuban within a few days. It seemed okay at first, no aggression at all, then overnight the Cuban was gone.
 
I tried it with no luck. Jag killed the cuban within a few days. It seemed okay at first, no aggression at all, then overnight the Cuban was gone.


Okay. ?? My other option would be to add either the juvenile- jag or the cuban in (125gallon -6ft ) with the rest of my juvenile: bocourti, friedrichsthalii, argentea, breidohri and eventually moving them to( 350gallon 8ft) ..

i guess my question would be between the two : jag or cuban which would work with that stock ?
 
I believe the possibility of the same problem between the Cuban, and managuense will also crop up with the friedrichthalii.
I would never keep two of the same genus (Parachromis, or a look alike such as Nandopsis) in the same tank.
You would not (or at least seldom) see those of the same genus Parachromis in nature together, because they are competitors, and this same problem is not alleviated in a aquarium, it is actually magnified because of the limited available space.
I have friends that are major Parachromis fans, and keep every Parachromis species of the genus in their tanks, but.... the long term successful of these Parachromic keepers is that, they do not keep different Parachromis species together, each species has its own tank, or is in a large enough community tank, with non-Parachromis cichlids.
I have also kept 2 Nandopsis species, and Parachromis at the same time, but like they did, not in the same tank. Probably why I always had 15 to 20 tanks running at the same time.
But this is not just a Parachromis thing, because in nature in any one geographical area, you seldom find 2 Vieja species, or 2 of some other genera together in close proximity.
In nature over time one species almost always edges the other out of existence. Thorichthys is about the only genus where you regularly find more than 1 species of Central American cichlid coexisting with the other, and this may be because they are innately social species.
 
MonsterFishKeepers.com