Jaguar id?

[TexOscar1]

I was wondering what these two jags were sex wise?
I tried venting but couldn't tell much of a difference. They are both about 6". Thank you in advance
First two pics are 1
Third pic is second jag.

 

[dan518]

Top male, bottom female shape but a pointed anal fin so not sure, how do they act to each other

 

[TexOscar1]

Haven't put them together yet. Letting the top one acclimate here. Got it on a trade

 

[TexOscar1]

I was hoping the colorful one was male

 

[pops]

hard call, tank bread jags hard to say till bigger. looks male male female.

 

[TexOscar1]

The colorful one killed 2 others that were same size if that helps. 1 I know was a male

 

[dan518]

When small females sometimes outgrow the males, males catch-up around six inch mark, that's what happened to me, mine at 5 inch dominant fish in the tank was female.

 

[ehh]

I think they both look male.

 

[TexOscar1]

Another pic of first fish.

 

[Tyler_Wentworth_150]

Looks like 2 males to me. But as was mentioned it's tough with tank bred jags until they get way bigger. My big male looked very female till he hit about 11". Then the barring faded and dorsal find began to point out