Lake fish as feeders?!

  • We are currently upgrading MFK. thanks! -neo

Michael6945c

Jack Dempsey
MFK Member
Mar 15, 2012
365
30
31
Dayton, Ohio
Ok so I just learned that my dad has been feeding his Oscar fresh minnows from the creek behind our house, I'm assuming it's not good for the Oscar but don't have anything to convince him it's wrong.. What could happen to the Oscar and why?


Sent from my iPhone using MonsterAquariaNetwork app
 
The minnows are wild and we can't control what they eat so unknowingly he might be bringing in parasites via minnow. Which can lead to major problems in the Oscar like premature death. Hope I helped a little. I didn't really go into details but u get the gist;)

Sent from my Nexus S 4G using MonsterAquariaNetwork App
 
The minnows are wild and we can't control what they eat so unknowingly he might be bringing in parasites via minnow. Which can lead to major problems in the Oscar like premature death. Hope I helped a little. I didn't really go into details but u get the gist;)

Sent from my Nexus S 4G using MonsterAquariaNetwork App

+1
 
^The above is about it. Wild caught fish can carry bad things with it, which well, can kill the oscar. Especially since the oscar is probably not wild-caught.

Quarantining the minnows before feeding would definitely minimize the risk.

But yeah besides possibly containing something that could harm the oscar, there really is nothing wrong with feeding your oscar wild minnows.
 
Yup and like they said quarantine. Lol regardless of wild caught or store bought feeders, quarantine is your friend haha. If he still insists on feeding wc minnows just set one up. Its not a guarantee that it'll be safe for him to eat but its a hella lot safer than sticking em in fresh haha

Sent from my Nexus S 4G using MonsterAquariaNetwork App
 
I used to do this when I lived on the lake. I wouldn't catch the minnows, but I'd buy them at bait shops for around 2 bucks a scoop, and a scoop was around 3 to 4 dozen good sized minnows, but these minnows were once caught in the lake. It was more to save money. I feed all of my fish store bought feeders now, but I would not hesitate going back to wild caught minnows, as long as I quarantine them first. I am now much more experienced and have lost fish in the past to parasites and illnesses. I would tell your dad to atleast quarantine the minnows before he feeds them to his oscar.
 
Tell your Dad that what he is doing is like playing Russian roulette with his Oscar.

Simply placing the minnows in to a quarantine tank, and observing them for disease and parasites for a few days/weeks is also far from fool proof. Wild fish can harbour any number of pathogens, most which cannot be seen with the naked eye, pathogens that a wild fish may have built up a natural immunity against. Introduce that same pathogen to a tank raised fish, that has no natural immunity for that pathogen, and the end result is typically a very sick (or possibly dead) fish.

Some might suggest to medicate the feeders, but to medicate indiscriminately can also cause its own set of problems. One needs to know exactly what they are treating for, or you risk strengthening the immunity of other pathogens & creating super bugs by using improper dosages. And who wants to be feeding mega medicated soaked feeders to their fish on a constant basis?

If your dad wants to feed live feeders, the safest & most responsible way is to raise his own. There are plenty of low cost fish that will produce tons of fry on a regular basis.
 
Tell your Dad that what he is doing is like playing Russian roulette with his Oscar.

Simply placing the minnows in to a quarantine tank, and observing them for disease and parasites for a few days/weeks is also far from fool proof. Wild fish can harbour any number of pathogens, most which cannot be seen with the naked eye, pathogens that a wild fish may have built up a natural immunity against. Introduce that same pathogen to a tank raised fish, that has no natural immunity for that pathogen, and the end result is typically a very sick (or possibly dead) fish.

Some might suggest to medicate the feeders, but to medicate indiscriminately can also cause its own set of problems. One needs to know exactly what they are treating for, or you risk strengthening the immunity of other pathogens & creating super bugs by using improper dosages. And who wants to be feeding mega medicated soaked feeders to their fish on a constant basis?

If your dad wants to feed live feeders, the safest & most responsible way is to raise his own. There are plenty of low cost fish that will produce tons of fry on a regular basis.
Well said and I agree completely.
 
I'm surprised that no one has mentioned this in addition yet. What about pollutants in the water? Maybe the minnows have higher than usual mercury levels, or whatever other chemicals are in your waterways. Mostly what RD said though.
 
Ok I talked to him and also bought him some pellets and he said he'll try a quarantine, what's a good fish to breed? I tried convicts but their numbers dwindled in the 20's quickly and never got big enough to feed any of my fish as a snack even.


Sent from my iPhone using MonsterAquariaNetwork app
 
MonsterFishKeepers.com