I called the company regarding it - they had me take off the top and look at the gasket - nothing obvious.
They actually were trying to be difficult about the warranty- I made sure I sent it in as soon as I got it. They sent an email that I could return the top piece and they may send another one after they looked at it.
They put in the text that they may assess it to not be worthy of sending me a replacement part and that they might damage the original. Not excited about this company anymore. It was the first time it was used as well.