I would probably add another set of the T5 coralifes.
one of thee issues you are seeing is not so much the brightness of the lights that is the problem, but rather, the light coverage, as the T5's are very close together in the fixture. so you have a narrow strip of really bright light, but around that its not as bright.
each 36" T5 double fixture should be good to properly light a 36x12" area, so adding a second set of two should be perfect.
if you decided to go with High Output T5s that are much brighter, they generally sit up on legs so they would light a larger width for the same length fixture.
but if your tank is not going to be planted, I would not go with High Outputs its going to be too bright. lots of algae otherwise.