Ok I dont mean to jack this thread, but i've been reading a lot of info and I can't seem to find the answers. I know this is a seriously noob question about saltwater tanks but I've just started reading. Whenever I read about live rock it's usually talked about as a primary source of biological filtration. Why would live rock be more beneficial than a really effective biological filtration system like a sump? I know saltwater fish are more sensitive to nitrates but they're not really ever a problem in a freshwater as long as you do water changes. So why exactly is it so essential if you had a sump or another form of filtration that converted ammonia to nitrite to nitrate?