M or F Red Devil?

  • We are currently upgrading MFK. thanks! -neo

MDH

Candiru
MFK Member
Jan 14, 2007
649
4
48
Canada, eh.
What are you thoughts? Reason I ask, I plan on getting this guy a mate soon, and need to figure out whether that mate will be male or female. My gut tells me male, but would like a 2nd opinion. Thanks!

2 months ago: (7.5")

P1010172.jpg

P1010203.jpg


Today (8.5"): (note that it just had a huge feed prior to taking these shots, hence the large belly)

P1010098.jpg

P1010071.jpg

P1010087.jpg
 
It is the same fish, just older and newer shots. Thanks for the input so far guys, keep em coming.
 
YAH, I THINK IT LOOKS LIKE A MALE, BUT AS OF NOW IS HE IN WITH ANY OTHER FISH? DOES HE BEAT THEM UP? IS HE DIGGING A NEST? IS HE REAL TERRITORIAL? IF YOU ANSWERED YES TO ALL THESE QUESTIONS, THEN IT IS VERY POSSIBLE HE IS A MALE. ALL THE FEMALE'S I'VE OWNED USUALY WOULDN'T BE AS AGRESSIVE UNTIL THEY HAVE HAD A MATE, BUT THATS JUST MY EXPERIENCE. MOST MALE'S ARE VERY TERRITORIAL ESPECIALY IF YOU TEASE THEM WITH YOUR FINGER THROUGH THE GLASS. I HOPE YOU FIND A GREAT MATE!!!!!
 
AMAZONPETS;1364831; said:
YAH, I THINK IT LOOKS LIKE A MALE, BUT AS OF NOW IS HE IN WITH ANY OTHER FISH? DOES HE BEAT THEM UP? IS HE DIGGING A NEST? IS HE REAL TERRITORIAL? IF YOU ANSWERED YES TO ALL THESE QUESTIONS, THEN IT IS VERY POSSIBLE HE IS A MALE. ALL THE FEMALE'S I'VE OWNED USUALY WOULDN'T BE AS AGRESSIVE UNTIL THEY HAVE HAD A MATE, BUT THATS JUST MY EXPERIENCE. MOST MALE'S ARE VERY TERRITORIAL ESPECIALY IF YOU TEASE THEM WITH YOUR FINGER THROUGH THE GLASS. I HOPE YOU FIND A GREAT MATE!!!!!

holy caps lock!
 
AMAZONPETS;1364831; said:
YAH, I THINK IT LOOKS LIKE A MALE, BUT AS OF NOW IS HE IN WITH ANY OTHER FISH? DOES HE BEAT THEM UP? IS HE DIGGING A NEST? IS HE REAL TERRITORIAL? IF YOU ANSWERED YES TO ALL THESE QUESTIONS, THEN IT IS VERY POSSIBLE HE IS A MALE. ALL THE FEMALE'S I'VE OWNED USUALY WOULDN'T BE AS AGRESSIVE UNTIL THEY HAVE HAD A MATE, BUT THATS JUST MY EXPERIENCE. MOST MALE'S ARE VERY TERRITORIAL ESPECIALY IF YOU TEASE THEM WITH YOUR FINGER THROUGH THE GLASS. I HOPE YOU FIND A GREAT MATE!!!!!

He's with a plceo. Digs constantly, is very territorial.. But i've never seen egg laying behaviour, nor eggs dropped. I've never seen big belly female signs like I have with my old female jag and convict. If it were female, would I not see this?
 
Going off the sexy bits it appears to be female. Males will be more narrow and drop straght down. Females will kind of hook.

I don't know what visual cues everyone else has gone off of, but the only sure-fire way to sex these fish is the vent.
 
Modest_Man;1365609; said:
Going off the sexy bits it appears to be female. Males will be more narrow and drop straght down. Females will kind of hook.

I don't know what visual cues everyone else has gone off of, but the only sure-fire way to sex these fish is the vent.
We can all see the "tube" clearly in those pics - thin and pointed. Definitely male.
 
MonsterFishKeepers.com