male or female silver aro

  • We are currently upgrading MFK. thanks! -neo
when they get older you can, the male has a more substantial lower jaw.
 
MistirE;813590; said:
when they get older you can, the male has a more substantial lower jaw.

sorry but ive seen females back in philippines that have " a more substantial lower jaw" :(

ntinos54;813538; said:
how can you tell the difference between the male and the female silver aro i was wondering ?

sorry but noone up to now is really sure how to identify them.
 
Are you sure? they are mouth broaders....the male holds all the fries in its mouth till they get old enough.....Anyhow, JUST a thought....not scientific proof from my statement.;)
 
MistirE;814367; said:
Are you sure? they are mouth broaders....the male holds all the fries in its mouth till they get old enough.....Anyhow, JUST a thought....not scientific proof from my statement.;)

yes im sure, and yes i know theyre mouth brooders. yes the male holds the fries but if u didnt know yet, sometimes if the eggs are too many, the female helps.
Only way to sex them to this date is by DNA testing. And / or if u see the aro lays eggs. ;)
 
HiGhTiMeZ;814390; said:
yes im sure, and yes i know theyre mouth brooders. yes the male holds the fries but if u didnt know yet, sometimes if the eggs are too many, the female helps.
Only way to sex them to this date is by DNA testing. And / or if u see the aro lays eggs. ;)


It is exactly like Hightimez states and no other way...beyond that there are tell tale signs, such as longer pectoral fins and proghnatic jaw for the male, but they're only tell tale...:)
 
Miguel;814410; said:
It is exactly like Hightimez states and no other way...beyond that there are tell tale signs, such as longer pectoral fins and proghnatic jaw for the male, but they're only tell tale...:)

Well, I guess I've been officially " MOTED ":ROFL:
No rebuttal from me :D
 
MistirE;814466; said:
Well, I guess I've been officially " MOTED ":ROFL:
No rebuttal from me :D

No Sireee, you've not been anything! You're above all, our Octopus expert!!!!!! And you're right, underjaw is a strong tell tale sign:) :) :) :)
 
There isn't anything that has been scientifically verified but I'm beginning to see differences amon silvers from my personal experience of having had four 20"+ aros. However, I know nearly for certain that the protrudedness or bulk of lower jaw, unfortunately, is not the most distinct sexual trait.

What I'm seeing are following distinct variables that are worth mentioning:

1. Length, width of overall finnage
2. Red vertical marking on the gill plate
3. Thickness of the body (not the height)
4. Sharpness, pointedness, and length of the extended end on pectoral fins
5. Red dots on the gill
 
angeladay;814803; said:
There isn't anything that has been scientifically verified but I'm beginning to see differences amon silvers from my personal experience of having had four 20"+ aros. However, I know nearly for certain that the protrudedness or bulk of lower jaw, unfortunately, is not the most distinct sexual trait.

What I'm seeing are following distinct variables that are worth mentioning:

1. Length, width of overall finnage
2. Red vertical marking on the gill plate
3. Thickness of the body (not the height)
4. Sharpness, pointedness, and length of the extended end on pectoral fins
5. Red dots on the gill


and all those "variables" point to what David? Male or female? And have you verified all that through confirmed pairing?
 
MonsterFishKeepers.com