My heart was nearly broken - how i almost hung up my poles - can you help?

  • We are currently upgrading MFK. thanks! -neo
Typically i like to fish away from the crowds. But this past weekend the lake was quite crowded. So I began my bass fishing adventure like any other, throwing hula poppers with great success. In fact I had a fantastic day overall, landing and releasing some real giants.

Then I happened upon this boat, anchored and throwing baited lines. Two men proceeded to land a largemouth and release it, because it was too small, so that was nice. But then they caught a 5 pound hog, and added it to a chain stringer of 4 other largemouth, hooked by the lip and dying at the side of their boat.

I hadn't seen a sight such as this one in many many years. In fact i have not seen it since the days of fishing with my dad and my uncle, where catch and kill was not only an option, it was law in my family. My father, an immigrant to this country believed that it was his duty to provide for his family, and animals on the table were a means to this end.

I swear to you, my hand to God, my stomach turned and i spent the rest of the day and the long drive home contemplating the sport that I love so dearly.

Look here, i don't judge people who follow the laws of the land in terms of what they can catch and keep - and I enjoy a shore lunch of a single non-super breeder fish as much as the next guy - but I cant come to terms with what i saw, 5 beautiful 5 pound largemouth ready to die.

I swear to you this has broken a small part of me, and i hope this post doesn't sound sappy or maudlin, but can you offer any advice or sympathy in regards to someone who loves sport fishing for largemouth, but cant quite wrap his mind around killing multiple fish or limits of large breeding fish.

I have no where else to vent what i saw this weekend.

I hadn't seen a bass kept, outside of being put in a live well, for so long, i wonder if part of my passion died that day too.

Am i so foolish to think that as a nation, we were over killing large breeding females, could I have been so wrong?

I wish the regulations were much stronger, like slot limits for bass - just to keep my romantic notions of the modern sportsman alive.


Sorry, this is not meant to be a rant or a attempt to pass judgement at all, and i mean no offense to those who catch and keep.

Perhaps i am devoted to the wrong sport.
 
You aren't devoted to the wrong sport, it's completely natural to get angry seeing people keep big bass. It's hard but the best way to deal with is think that there are hundreds upon hundreds of big bass like that in the lake and even though those selfish individuals are doing that the population will survive. I too believe big bass should all be released and honestly do not understand why the red drum slot limit is 1 fish per day between 18 and 27" while the largemouth slot is so open to anybody who gets lucky minnow fishing. Don't give up your sport, you love it and you make a difference by releasing the ones that you do catch and setting an example for your kids if they like to fish. Hopefully wildlife services will get their head out of their arse and close the slot down to smaller fish, perhaps be able to keep fish in a slot of 10"-18". Smaller bass taste better or so i've heard, and a lot of small ponds that don't have any fish removed end up with 0 bream and hundreds of cookie cutter 10-12" fish that can't get bigger because their only food source is bugs or mosquitofish. I understand where you're coming from but it's no reason to quit doing something you love
 
just cuz there really is no reason for it in todays world, if they needed it for food it would be more cost effective and they'd get more meat catfishing or catching bream, it's just sheer arrogance so they can go home and say 'hey look what we caught!', they havent discovered the invention of the camera yet lol
 
no love for the panfish? :P j/k haha

My personal thoughts are that they should enforce stricter freshwater limits and enforce much stricter saltwater COMMERCIAL fishing limits. Recreational fishing in the ocean isn't enough to even make a tiny dent, but the commercial fishing kills everything, i think we're to a point in the world where saltwater food fish can be farmed and bred rather than having to be pulled from the wild, would reduce the risk of mercury etc as well
 
Its fishing...

Im not against you or anything, but what can we do.
 
continue practicing C&R and hoping that regulations come to stop those who dont, thats about all
 
MonsterFishKeepers.com