Need an I.D. pls.

[downsouth]

Hi everyone, I just need to get an I.D. for this fish right here:

Thanks in advance!
http://img370.imageshack.us/img370/517/img0207kh5.jpg

 

[Edwin]

red hook
or something like that.

 

[benzjamin13]

Red Hook Silver Dollars

 

[joel]

silver dollar

 

[dark_knights_99]

What they said.

 

[killerfish]

yep those are red hooks

 

[channarox]

aye,red hook.

 

[downsouth]

So there's no chance this is a Myleus Myleus schomburgki a.k.a. blacked bar red hook and the black bars are just in the process of developing?

I got 7 of these and was told it was a blacked bar red hook and ofcourse paid much more.

BTW for reference this is the Myleus schomburgki "blacked bar red hook"

the one that I got that was labled "blacked bar red hook"

and one of my red hook

I hope our experts in this species would give their opinion.

Thanks!

 

[channarox]

how big are they?
ive seen black barred red hooks with the bars at less than 2 inches

 

[downsouth]

how big are they?
ive seen black barred red hooks with the bars at less than 2 inches

I got 2 3" and the rest are 2".

Are there cases wherein the bars don't develop or develops late?

Thanks channarox!