need help fast.

  • We are currently upgrading MFK. thanks! -neo

akvamania

Feeder Fish
MFK Member
Dec 7, 2005
38
0
0
44
norway
hey.

sorry for my bad english wrigting.

i need help, in 2-4 days im gettin 2 Hydrocynus goliath:WHOA: . annyone her has some experience.
can i keep these with other large fish like a.labiatum.
or do i have to keep these in a speesies tank.
 
For tankmates, the only fish that won't be smashed are other individuals of the same size. Aquarium furnishings would only get in the way,

I would suggest a bare tank, no gravel etc..

I wouldn't get 2 unless your tank is huge. that's just my opinion. 1000+ gal.

g'luck anyway!

:thumbsup:
 
Hiya Akvamania, I vcan't help you because I have never kept them but I would like to say welcome to MFK.
 
i have a 500 litres tank with 4 larger red devils in and a large pleco, all other fish i wil remove. teh goliaths are no bigger then max 20 cm when i get them and so are teh red devils. this is only a short solution, i hava a 1800 litres tank comming soon.
 
akvamania - you're going to keep the ATFs with the red devils? In all likelyhood a 20 cm red devil is going to bash a 20 cm hydrocynus. I would not risk it.
 
akvamania - you're going to keep the ATFs with the red devils? In all likelyhood a 20 cm red devil is going to bash a 20 cm hydrocynus. I would not risk it.

so you mean i shuld keep them in a tank for them selvs?
i cant take any risk with them. expencive.

until i get my larg tank i only have a 80 l and a 125 litres free. can i keep them i that for a short wild,for 2 weeks or so? if not im gonna have to get a larger tank to morow.
 
i wonder, how much did you other goliath owners pay for your tigers? here in norway i payd 1200 nkr ech in usd tht should be about 200 $
 
akvamania IF they really are goliaths, which you can't say until you receive them and post pics, then 200$ for a 20 cm is a very good deal. If they are vitattus it's still a decent deal :)

And ak, trust me, you put those ATFs in the red devils's tank where they've already established territory they'll be picked on relentlessly and probably die. ATFs squabble with each other, but are not bully fish or fighters. They are just pure predators really. They don't tend to fight other fish like wolves, snakeheads, and cichlids. Sometimes they kill fish, but they're not fighty fish.

I would not rist it at all. They need a big tank too, even temporarily DON'T put them in an 80 litre or 125 litre, they'll be nervous and they'll probably damage their snouts as they dart around, and knock their teeth out. They have to go into your 500l until you get your big tank.

I would take the devils out and put them in the 125l, leave the plecos, then when you get your big tank put the devils back in the 500l, and the hydros in the big tank.

Don't keep the hydros with cichlids, at least not until they are over 30 cm. Keep them with peaceful characins and bichirs.

Also have you seen this fish? I don't wanna ruin your trip, but in all likelyhood they are not goliath. Real goliaths are very rare, so many ATFs are marketed as goliath but almost all of them are vittatus or sometimes forskalii. Only 2 or 3 people on here actually have a real goliath.

Here are some pics, not mine.... here is a vittatus, notice the short snout and dotted stripes on the body and the tail...

191.jpg


Now here is a goliath, I'm sure you can see the difference...

attachment.php


As yours are 20 cm, not babies, they'll be very easy to ID.

GOod luck, and they are cool whatever they are.
 
MonsterFishKeepers.com