It looks like you're going backward...((4a+4h)/(a+h-5)-((4a)/(a-5))
let x = 4a and y= a-5
now you have ((x+4h)/(y+h))-((x)/(y))
get a common denominator yields
(xy+4hy-xy-hx)/((y)(y+h)) = (4hy-hx)/((y)(y+h)) = h(4y-x)/((y)(y+h)
replace the variables x and y
and finish the work -> let me know if I made a mistake
How could you say you showed every step when you asked him to "replace the variable x and y and finish the work?"not backwards...
I made it easier to solve (in my opinion) by replacing repeated information.
You start by making the problem simpler than once you have the final equation, you replace your variable with the correct values and finish the problem. I did the same thing you did except I showed every step...
Also, you forgot the 1/h from the original formula