need some help: fish ID

[hansolo5589]

can you guys tell me what type of fish this is? would really appreciate it thou.

thanks guys,,,...

 

[peewee]

first pic looks like a convict

 

[harry1227]

I agree , I think it's a convict.

 

[Angler]

It's not a Convict. A Mayan perhaps.

 

[hansolo5589]

mayann...lol....i would agree on the convict thou.....alrite guys ...how about the second one...and is it bad having those convicts...in the tank...??

 

[Angler]

mayann...lol....i would agree on the convict thou.....alrite guys ...how about the second one...and is it bad having those convicts...in the tank...??

Alright, fish genius

Convicts:

Mayan:

 

[kevinfleming21]

the top guy is a mayan ......no doubt

 

[Citrinellus]

I agree, they both appear to be mayans. Also know as false red terrors.

 

[balton777]

mayann...lol....i would agree on the convict thou.....alrite guys ...how about the second one...and is it bad having those convicts...in the tank...??

Why did you dismiss Angler's opinion so quickly? I would take his ID before the guy with 1 post. They both look like Uro's to me too except the second one is rather washed out and has a lot of spangling on it's gill. I haven't seen that before but it still looks Mayan or Mayan x something.

 

[Sab_Fan]

It's not a Convict. A Mayan perhaps.

I agree . . . despite the ignorant comments made above