Never listen to the wife or LFS staff.

  • We are currently upgrading MFK. thanks! -neo

esoxlucius

Balaclava Bot Butcher
MFK Member
Dec 30, 2015
3,995
15,468
209
UK
So, we went to the local garden centre today. My missus wanted to go because they have started stocking all the xmas stuff, she wanted to get a few ideas.

Within the garden centre there is a section for fish, not just outdoor pond fish, but also tropical fish. We always start off in that section so I can have a look at fish.

Now my missus isn't exactly into my hobby, it's more of a perseveres with it type of agreement. So imagine my delight when she took some interest in some cute little catfish. They were being sold as "shark catfish". Beautiful little things about 2" apiece. She wanted some but I knew nothing about them at all and I usually make it a rule that I do my research on a fish before purchase.

But my missus was showing an interest in my hobby, get a couple of these fish, keep her sweet and who knows, good leverage for an upgrade further down the road, you know how it works.

So I thought i'd go against the grain for the sake of the missus and solely rely on the advice of the store guy. I asked him what size they grew to, whether my other fish, and plants, were safe. The answers I got were promising. Only grows to 8" or so, peaceful with other fish and prefers planted aquariums. He also said it does better in groups, so my missus said, let's get three!

So we gets home, first thing I did was get on the Internet for these "shark catfish". They have a whole host of common names but the one that matters, and the pictures proved it, were that the three fish i'd purchased were indeed "hexanematichthys seemani". Now you catfish guys will probably be familiar with this species.

It can get to 20" in length, it does better in brackish water and once it gets to a certain size it will consider the rest of my stock as food!!! Not details shared by the store guy!

Now I can take these cute little guys back, no problem, if what I read is completely true. I also read some online forum reports that these guys were a very placid and active non aggressive species that were a welcome addition to a community tank.

HELP! am I better taking them back or am I worrying needlessly.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Jacob92677
I’d suggest taking it back. My friend had a large Columbian catfish. It was over 15in some years ago. It also prefers brackish water and eventually full salt when adult . It can hit the 20in mark if properly taken care of and will eat whatever fits in it’s mouth when that large. Need a 6ft tank if kept for life.
 
I would return the catfish.
 
Cute little cats returned for store credit. And the guy who give me BS info on them got a steely eyed glare from Mrs Esox. I was going to say something to him but the glare from my wife was enough punishment for him, haha.
 
Hoplo catfish could be a decent alternative. Certainly more personable than the other.
 
Hoplo catfish could be a decent alternative. Certainly more personable than the other.

I'll be honest with you, i'm not a great fan of catfish, I was just stupid yesterday, going totally against the grain and impulse buying just to try and get the wife more interested in my hobby.

The moral of the story is simple, and one we are all too familiar with, always do your own research on your fish before buying and as a general rule don't take any notice of LFS employees. Maybe a bit harsh but certainly applicable in my situation yesterday.

It all turned out well in the end anyway.
 
Too bad you weren't refunded your money but the store credit offer was about what I expected.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Chicxulub
Here in Panama they are a favorite catch of fishermen, that catch them (or similar species) in brackish estuaries, and sold to locals and restaurants alike.

They clean them in the fishing boats, tossing the guts and heads overboard, but the heads seem to wash up on the beach, and litter the sand until the vultures notice the smorgasbord, and clean it all up.

 
MonsterFishKeepers.com