Newcomer: QUIETEST/CHEAPEST Air filter for 20 Gal fresh/coldwater

  • We are currently upgrading MFK. thanks! -neo

albirdy

Feeder Fish
MFK Member
May 5, 2008
361
0
0
39
Bay area, California
Hello! The title is pretty much self-explanatory. I am a new-comer to the aquarium game, and my tank is currently beginning it's cycling (thank you responders to my first thread!) I am going to purchase an air filter ASAP, and wanted to know your advice.

Thank you so much!
 
Welcome! I'm not sure what you mean by air filter. There are Power Filters, Canister Filters, Sponge Filters, Fluidized Sand Filters, etc. Good luck fishkeeping and don't hesitate if you have any questions.
 
I think he means an air powered sponge filter. A power filter (the ones that hang on the back of the aquarium) would work better, but a sponge filter would probably suffice.
 
Ah, thank you, thank you for specifying! Haha, I guess that shows you just how much of an amateur I am to this game.

So yes, I got an Aqua Clear 50 (200) power filter. (Although I'm still unsure what the other ones are... like what's a sponge filter?)

I understand that there are different layers of filtration in this device. What are they, and are there any trick to the trade when it comes to setting up and maintaining it?
 
well if you want to get the filter working quicker you can get some established media from a friend or lfs and add it to the filter to speed up cycling . if the filter has carbon in it remove it and replace with a fine spong from a lfs or batting material found in furniture shop. save the carbon to remove meds if you ever need them .
 
Check the stickies at the top of the page. I can give you a brief description of the different filtration types though. First is mechanical, which simply filters out solid particles. In an AC, that will be the sponge.

Then there is chemical which removes...chemicals. That is the activated carbon. Chemical isn't really neccessary, unless you need to remove medicine, tannins, etc from the water.

Then the most important is biological filtration. Thats the biomax stuff in an AC. The media has lots of surface area, which bacteria colonize. These bacteria convert ammonia, which comes from fish waste, uneaten food, or anything else thats decaying, into nitrite. Ammonia and Nitrite are very toxic to fish. Different bacteria convert the nitrItes into nitrAtes, which then can be removed with water changes. You can't just add a bunch of fish as soon as the tank is setup, because it needs to cycle. You have to wait a few weeks for the bacterial colonies to grow. Adding a few hardy fish works, or you can use filter media from a tank that has been running and is cycled already.


Mechanical filter media needs to be rinsed out and replaced every month or so, depending on how much of a mess your fish make. Carbon needs to be replaced to, or it will stop working. Don't mess with the biomedia though, except rinsing it in tank water if you need to. Otherwise you can kill the bacteria.


If you have an AC 50, thats plenty of filtration. You may be think of an air pump, not filter. The pump is to blow bubbles in the tank, which agitates the surface, and allows more gas exchange (oxygen into the water, and CO2 out) I have 2 whisper air pumps. They work fine, and are quiet enough that I don't hear it unless the cabinet is open.

A sponge filter works by pulling water through a sponge, and they work well for smaller tank

Hang-on-Back/HOB/power filters pump water out of the tank and through the media, and then the water flows back in over the little waterfall-looking part. You have a HOB.

Canisters are a lot bigger, and used mainly for large tanks. Water flows out of the tank and down into the canister, which is usually kept in the stand, where it travels through the media and is then pumped back up into the tank. They are more difficult to maintain, and more expensive.

Then there are wet/dry sump filters. A sump is a separate tank that water drains into. Water trickles over the media, which isn't fully submerged, and is then pumped back into the tank by a separate pump. They cost a lot unless you make it yourself.

here are some useful articles to read about filtration: http://www.monsterfishkeepers.com/forums/showthread.php?t=94937
http://www.monsterfishkeepers.com/forums/showthread.php?t=88677
 
FSM;1768867; said:
Mechanical filter media needs to be rinsed out and replaced every month or so, depending on how much of a mess your fish make.

True but albirdy had made a good choice of buying an AquaClear. The mechanical filtration (sponge) only needs to be rinsed and almost never replaced. I've replaced the sponge on my AC110/500 exactly once in 10+ years.

BTW, always rinse your sponges in aquarium water out of the tank. This way you won't have to use tap water which will kill your beneficial bacteria.
 
FSM;1768867; said:
If you have an AC 50, thats plenty of filtration. You may be think of an air pump, not filter. The pump is to blow bubbles in the tank, which agitates the surface, and allows more gas exchange (oxygen into the water, and CO2 out) I have 2 whisper air pumps. They work fine, and are quiet enough that I don't hear it unless the cabinet is open.


So, do I need an air pump as well?
 
MonsterFishKeepers.com