ok, need suggested filtration and water movement equip

  • We are currently upgrading MFK. thanks! -neo

hotsauce

Feeder Fish
MFK Member
Feb 16, 2008
532
1
0
san diego
ok so i had a few fish die, now lfs staff has made me second guess setup currently- 100gal, 80%playsand/20%gravel substrate, canopy/shop light dual florescent bulb, fluval 403, large air pump/one 4" air stone. keeping native species- lmb, catfish, bluegill. also any opinions on replacing fluval carbon with eheim pro media(not sure of name exactly) :(
 
lfs suggested replacing carbon with eheim pro biomedia, also adding another canister filter, and powerhead. says natives very messy and suggests gravel insted of sand. help please!
 
Right off the hop, I'd agree you're underfiltered unless you've only 2 or 3 fish in that tank. I would at least double that but if your tank is lightly stocked, then simply upgrading your media and doing larger water changes would probably improve conditions considerably. I'd never use carbon unless I was pulling meds or discolouration out of the water. Eheim makes a good product, but pricey. I've also had good luck with Purigen added as a second media.

As for the substrate, I have converted almost all my tanks to sand. Gravel holds too much crud in it. Sand allows for a cleaner tank since removing the crud ismuch easier.
 
water test were, all good except nitrate between 40-80ppm. ammonia 0.0, ph 7.8. this was my first time using sand and ive tried to keep up on cleaning but i think i stirred too much of it up. if your not usins carbon, what do you use chaitika? the lfs also said with the addtional fluval and eheim biopro media(at $42 a box) will make it to where i just have to change sponges 90 days and media once a year
 
most of the filtration media are made of the same material, the only exception is the packaging which is designed to fit correctly into your filter's media compartment.

bio media serves a very specific purpose, which is to provide greater surface area for beneficial bacteria to colonize... that's it. so whatever brand that fits in your filter will do the job. i don't even use carbon anymore, since it has to be replaced and the costs can add up. it's not a necessary media unless you're trying to remove medication or other chemicals that you've added [accidentally] in your tank.

sand is actually an excellent substrate for messy fish, because sand is very compact, so there are very little crevices where uneaten food or other organic waste may settle. so what's on the surface of the sand can be easily removed manually or via filtration. gravel, on the other hand, is big and gets very dirty very quickly.

i'd suggest that you add another filter, since canister filters are exceptionally powerful when it comes to aerating your water, you probably won't have the need for a separate powerhead.

as for your fish dying, that could be a whole other discussion in itself. i have no idea why unless you give us more details on your water quality, parameter readings and what are your regular tank maintenance that you carry out.
 
ML thanks for the advice. im thinking i may have made my biggest mistake by adding a piece of wood i got from a local little lake and didnt boil it like i did with my other 2 pieces. also i think i may stirred up to much of the sand releasing to much nitrate. i did 10% w/changes for the past three weeks every weekend. it was setup alittle over a month ago. then this past saturday i did a 50% and decor rearrange because i was adding to fish, and my lmb was over aggresive so i thought it would help. but i killed them. so starting over. any advice and helpful info would be great.
 
MonsterFishKeepers.com