Older tank = less silicone?

  • We are currently upgrading MFK. thanks! -neo

Totalimmortal

Gambusia
MFK Member
Mar 12, 2008
236
0
16
Westminster, CO
I just picked up a used 125, a little older tank. The corners have a VERY small amount of silicone. It's almost as if the glass is bonded together where they meet, and that's it.

It's honestly kinda scary as I've never seen a tank with so little silicone. Am I just crazy?

It's defiantly glass, I know what the corners of an acrylic tank looks like.
 
Here you see where the side attaches to the front pane of glass, literally no silicone outside of the joint.

photo1-2.jpg


Here you can see the silicone that attaches the side to the front, thin layer.

photo2-2.jpg
 
The silicone outside the joint actually does very little to hold a tank together. It is pretty much all in between the two pains of glass. Most tanks actually have more than you really even need. Too much can cause more issues than good. Chances are you will be fine so long as what's there is in good shape.
 
That makes me feel a bit better, although I've got an opposing view on cichlid-forum.com right now.

I'm seriously worried to be honest. If anyone else has anything else to say, please do!
 
on my 16 year old miracles tank (domestic brand in canada) I had almost no excess silicone left. over the years it had worn away and been rasped away by my royal pleco. the tank still didn't leak.

the thing to remember is that tanks have two seals:

primary seal (what is actually between the glass only)

secondary seal (all the excess you see in the corners). this does nothing to hold water in the tank. it just serves to protect the primary seal.

Aqueon (aka All Glass) tanks for example, refer to their secondary seal as a 'cone seal' over top of the structural (primary seal) - I just was conversing with their aquarium department over a silicone question I had with my 150g, so I got the scoop LOL. the tanks are 'double sealed' in with two seals as I described above.

So, as long as your primary seal is fine, the tank should not leak.

chances are, as this is an older tank, it was similar to mine -it used to have more of a secondary seal but it got worn away from aggressive algae scrubbing, fish picking, or algea growing underneath the outer edge and pushing up the secondary seal a bit. this makes it easier for it to peel off as the tank gets on in years.

since there is no secondary seal left, its easy to reseal the tank because the secondary seal is already gone.

all you have to do is add your own. you could easily do a reseal on this tank by adding new silicone into the corners if you are concerned. when you reseal a tank, this is actually what you are doing: you strip away all the secondary seal and redo that. you generally never touch the primary seal. it remains intact and you dont seperate the glass panels ever.

hope this helps!
 
I agree 100% with was 12 Volt has to say, he's got it right. You'll find there are a lot of people that think they know everything when it comes to making tanks. These are often the people who also give out bad info.

If your worried, as said above, you can always add more silicon to help protect, but its not needed. I would do a leak test somewhere safe at the very least however.
 
MonsterFishKeepers.com