Oscar and Clownknife??

[Dovii dude]

Is it wise to keep these 2 fish together??I have my O in an 80 gal tank with a large Silver dollar and a 4-5 inch Clownnife,my O is about 6 inches.Any help is appreciated!!!

 

[benzjamin13]

I had my Oscar with a Royal and a Clown. They do fine. But it does depend on how your Oscar is with other fish. My Oscar was a gentle giant.

 

[Dovii dude]

Well when i first put my Oscar"Bubba" in the tank he went after my Silver Dollar and Clownknife,but now he seems fine,but my Clownknife seems a little uneasy he used to be the bully of my tank,but my Oscar has seemed to calm him down.

 

[Daniel Machado]

It depends on your fishes, but it can surely work, IMO.

Best regards.

Daniel.

 

[jsodwi]

I have a 10" oscar and a 12" royal they seem ok together

 

[Stang1]

I have 2 12''+ O's in with my clownknife and they get along just fine

 

[rallysman]

Currenty I have 2 knives (13 and 16") and 11ish" oscar...the never mess with each other

 

[Dovii dude]

The only problem i seem to be having is i think that the Clownknife is nipping everybody in the tank.My Silver Dollar is nipped up,And my Oscar is also nipped up on his fin.